Siena's Pizza 321 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

"I have gone to this pizza place/ restaurant a half dozen times in the last year. We had a really good experience the first time when we ordered a pizza to go. After that, over the five other times we ordered items to go, we ordered pizzas along with Stromboli, calzone, wings, house salad, and chicken Parmigian. We had mixed results but all-in-all the food was really not good. All the food, except for the 1st pizza and the chicken parm dinner, was bad. The wings were not well seasoned and were greasy, the calzone was bland, all the pizzas but the 1st pizza were made with almost no cheese and no Italian seasoning, the Strombolis were made with way too much ham and not enough spicy meats (salami and pepperoni) and there was no spicy ham (capicola). On top of that, this place is a bit on the pricy side. The last time I went there (one day ago) was the worst. The pizza was so bad my wife actually got sick. I ate one slice and then half way through the 2nd slice I threw it away. We both threw away the wings, and the Stromboli was greasy and tasteless - I ate only one piece. It was so bad I had to go back and ask for my money back. I gave him back all the uneaten food and he had the nerve to give me back less than half of what I paid. We will never go back there again."

"Usually we order from Broadway pizza, tonight they were closed so we ordered from here for the first time & I was disappointed. Pizza came cold, not even the box was warm, & the garlic knots came cold aswell & didn’t taste right.."

"Amazing pizza, love the salads; always fresh ingredients and great heros! Also they deliver.! And did I mention how good the pizza was?! Haha"

"Nice pie. $12.96 for a 14-in Neapolitan pizza pie. Hard price to beat and the flavors just great. Stay away from the calamari. It's not fresh. It's from Frozen and has no flavor. Gyro is pretty good."

"Got $250 worth of food for a client lunch. Chicken wings were awful! Chicken Parmesan and pizza were okay. Baked ziti was actually good. Service was adequate. I will try other places before returning."