The Kaatskeller

"Delicious pizza - the Margherita is amazing. Make a reservation in the winter. Indoor seating is limited"

"As seasoned reviewers, my boyfriend and I recommend this Catskills pizza spot, giving it a commendable 8.2. The atmosphere, both indoors and outdoors, was superb. The staff was friendly, enhancing the overall experience. Our culinary journey included a wood-fired roasted trout appetizer, which, unfortunately, scored a 5 due to its mushiness and an incompatible onion-rice mix. As a non-garlic eater, the pesto was overwhelmingly garlicky. The Waterfowl folly Rueben sauerkraut pizza earned an 8 for its well-structured dough, while the Hawaii Five-Oh disappointed with an excessive amount of cheese and pineapple, resulting in a rating of 3. The drinks, particularly the "Lost in the Woods" cocktail and the draft beer, received an 8 and were truly delightful. The arugula salad stood out with a stellar rating of 9."

"Not that much room inside for huge groups, but they got a fire going for us and was awesome even better. Pizza is great and super cool spot. Highly recommend."

"This place is a great find. The pizza is excellent, and they have a gluten-free crust you can substitute with any pizza. Best GF crust i've had! Not only is the pizza something all on its own, but their speciality and infused drinks/cocktails are just as great. Definitely worth the trip even if you have to travel a little. Highly recommend."

"Our first visit to the town coming from New Haven, CT and NYC. We chose this excellent restaurant to fill our bellies en route to Ithaca. The lines of people waiting to get in was the first indication this was worthy of the experience. Scott, the manager, greeted us. We were offered indoor or outdoor. Scott brought us to this wonderful upstairs space which delighted us with the music and the staff. Top notch service. Ambience is hip and the music delightful. The beer was on tap and definitely tasty. The pizza brought the house down!!! Yum yum yum!! You need to make this your favorite spot when heading north. Easy drive into town with plenty of street parking. Easy access back onto old route 17. We are all smiles still bragging about the amazing experience! The staff is perfect by the way!!!"