The Christopher 24 South Water Street, Edgartown, MA 02539

"Always a delight. One night we got home too late for cookies and the manager made fresh ones for us. We stayed here for years when it was Victorian Inn and Lark has only built upon what Steve and Karin created."

"The Christopher Hotel is an absolute gem in the heart of Edgartown. If you are a Jaws enthusiast, you will love this location. In addition to the front of the Christopher hotel appearing in the movie, Jaws, the kitchen in the Christopher is also the set of the coroners office scene in the Jaws film. Aside from the movie fame, this hotel is in the heart of downtown. You can literally park your car and spend a weekend just walking around the local town. Thanks to 3rd and 4th generation islander recommendations you will enjoy the finest cuisine in the area within walking distance of The Christopher. The local people in all the shops and restaurants are probably some of the nicest people we have ever met, and made us feel like family within minutes of meeting. The rooms at The Christopher are clearly newly renovated in a beautiful nautical design and the gorgeously varnished banister leads you up to your rooms. Once we entered our room you could clearly see all the wood work/wood staining and all of the beautifully executed renovations they did. The bedding/ comforter were perfectly executed, clean and crisp and bath towels were also perfectly cleaned and crisp. I cannot say enough about the main suite, bathroom, balcony, and the balcony view from our room which overlooked the beautiful garden area. At night the garden area has a gorgeous gas fire feature which is cozy and inviting. If you enjoy star gazing, you will love to just lean your head back and enjoy the skies from this location. The staff at The Christopher were some of the greatest hosts we have ever had the pleasure of meeting. Neusa and Ellen were like family to us while we were here. The banana bread they brought out in the morning was absolutely delicious!!! We went down for more than one helping!!! Not to mention the giant fresh baked chocolate chip cookies that just drew us out of our room! We will definitely be revisiting The Christopher and would highly recommend staying here!!!"

"We were there on our honeymoon. We also specifically told them it was our honeymoon when we booked. We ended up next to a couple with two very noisy children... At times, it felt like the children were in the room with us! Luckily, they checked out the second day. The sheets are cheap microfiber with random hair all over it! Just everything stuck to it! Drove me nuts for 5 days! I immediately notice all the hair upon our arrival (before sitting or laying or touching the bed), they changed the sheets. However, every time the room was serviced there would be new hair! They clearly did not vacuum the room before our arrival because the floor also had random hair all over the carpet.This would stick to our feet then to the cheap sheets. I complained, as we were headed out for the day. They said they would take care of it, and they didn’t. I kept taking sheets out of the closet and changing my bed myself ( with lint roller to assist). I have never experienced something like this issue before, and I have traveled a lot and stayed at many hotels ranging from low to high end. They need to invest in regular linen sheets, and have a better laundry process. For the price, I wish we had just stayed at Harbor View which is more expensive but has more amenities, and likely not a hair problem! The breakfast was good. Lobby was decorated nice. Location good."

"Our stay truly could not have been better. I was somewhat anxious about our MV experience during COVID and reached out in advance of our stay MANY times with questions and they were so gracious in answering and were always so helpful. Marla was great during our stay - she had very helpful advice and lots of great recommendations. Everyone was so friendly! Our trip was celebrating our 10-year anniversary and they left us the sweetest note and cute little sparkling wine bottles. These type of touches are what raise the bar of good service up to 5-star to me. We were in the Lark Suite for the first part of our stay which was just amazing with a perfect private balcony. We decided late in the game to extend our stay and our room was booked so we moved to a first floor queen. The Lark Suite was obviously a bigger and nicer room but the queen was great as well! Much roomier than I expected and both beds were equally comfortable :) the only downside to that room is that you can hear people coming in/out and coming down the stairs. Overall a great stay and they worked with us to extend our stay and make the room switch was seamless as possible. The property itself is also beautiful with gorgeous decor. It’s in a GREAT location. On the cutest street and in walking distance to all the restaurants and shops you could want. I HIGHLY recommend. You MUST stay here. I hope we get to return!"