Mario's Pizza 186 Broadway, Port Ewen, NY 12466

"Ayy I love ordering a mushroom pie and then getting a white pie w sad chicken on it. Tried to call back and just went to voicemail. Comp me"

"The food was ok,we should have read the to go menu better ,we did not realize that an order of wings was 6 wings. The calzone does not come with sauce ,it has to be ordered separately .but that is not the restaurant fault it was ours for not paying better attention Overall an ok experience"

"Food is excellent, no question. However. Ordered by phone for delivery. 2 hours later im still waiting. I could WALK to the place in ten minutes. To be fair I was told an hour. But that's an hour not two. I'll tell you this though they sure didn't waste any time charging my credit card. They got their money in 15 minutes. Now I'm just hungry and frustrated.... Update, diver was SUPER apologetic, apparently they had some kind of breakdown. Food is good , not hot but still warm. But undeniably delicious. Def will order again."

"FOOD HAZARD ALERT Bought a big order of food today when we visited Port Ewen from out of town. When I opened my sub for dinner, I gave a bite to a piece of plastic.... could have been my toddler instead. Waiting for the owner to deal with this incident here in the Reviews section. Will report back."

"Saddest Margherita pizza I've ever gotten. There was no flavor to the sauce. Def not fresh mozzarella and not one atom of fresh basil. Maybe if they put some salt and basil, I might have given this 2 stars. Should have saved my money and gotten a digiorno. Teens working the phones and counter and they barely had any customer service skills."