Hartsdale House of Pizza 914-722-2666

"First time here for me. A Detroit and a regular slice. The only Detroit they had was what looked to me like an "Everything" ... included pepperoni, sausage, onion, regular sauce, vodka sauce, ham ... would have preferred a regular or pepperoni Detroit. Will try to come back some time earlier in the day because maybe at that point that's all they had left. The Detroit was heavy. It was definitely the better of the two slices. For me, too much cheese on the top layer which overwhelmed the other ingredients. Others may have different preferences and may be ok with this. The plain slice was disappointing. Again, overwhelmed with too much cheese (and I like cheese!). Sauce could have been tastier. And while the crust did have some crunch to it near the center, it did have some flop as I ate towards the outside. Again, certainly ok for some, I prefer my pizza with a crunch to it. Good to have another option for Detroit style. I note a few other reviews that complained about the counter service. They were not nasty and certainly fine, but I do think they could have been a bit friendlier and a few more smiles couldn't hurt. Will give it another try sometime."

"Really nice neighborhood place. It is more of a takeout spot but the food is very good. The arugula salad with apples is delicious and so are a lot of their sandwiches. They really do use good ingredients. Everything I have had has always tasted fresh. Keep up the good work guys !"

"Consistently the best pizza in New York! High quality, custom pizzas, numerous flavor profiles you won't find anywhere else, deserving of a cult following. Restaurant quality alternative (to pizza) entrée items from paninis to shrimp scampi. Down to earth, friendly owner's and operators. My wife and I order at least once a week from here and not always pizza b/c their other options are just as good as their pizza. Below is a list of recommendations/what we order and we're always satisfied and happy we ordered from Hartsdale House of Pizza. *Bruschetta Pie (square) *Cacio e Pepe Pie (square) *The Bronx House (square) *1/2 Bianco & 1/2 Tartufo Pie (round) *1/2 Bianco & 1/2 Buffalo Chicken Pie (round) *Shrimp Scampi *Penne Alla Vodka *Grilled Chicken, Broccoli Rabe, Provolone Panini"

"Hartsdale House of Pizza recently opened in the Village of Hartsdale. They have an extensive menu with delicious pizzas as well as paninis and great salads. As a result of the pandemic, they are only operating for take out and deliveries. Today I picked up pizza dough! I love to think that I can make my own pizzas and fortunately, they were happy to sell me two that were freshly made and will make me regret that I didn’t order one of their exceptional pies! I love their Salad Pie and their Classic Cheese Pizzas."