Angela's Pizza 1923 Route 9W, Lake Katrine, NY 12449

"Decided to give this place one more chance since the new ownership and I absolutely will not be ordering from here anymore! I ordered curly fries, which were mostly hard. And chicken wings. The chicken wings were very over cooked and dry, and the chicken meat had a nasty flavor to it. Never again!"

"Ordered online, when delivered pizza looked like it was dropped and half the cheese was off to one side. Delivery person was courteous. Garlic bread was fantastic, pizza was disappointing due to reasons above."

"Very cozy pizza place. I stopped in on my way back from a job out in that area. I love the cozy atmosphere inside. The pizza was great! They've got a dine-in special for a large pie that's I believe $11. Can't beat that deal these days. I got two slices to stay, and I asked the staff to only warm it up a little, as the pies were pretty well done and I prefer mine less well done. They kept it in a little longer than I would've liked, but it was still delicious! If you like your pies well done, you're in the right place. If you don't, remember to ask for it less well done. I recommend this cozy little stop for sure!"

"This place feels like it hasn't changed in 100 years, the pizza is good, the people are fine, it's just a low key good pizza restaurant. The slices are a little expensive now, but solid quality. It's a nice, quiet pizzeria that is refreshing to visit because everything around here is so upscale and pretentious and this is just a humble pizzeria like you would have had a glass of sangria and in 1990"

"Stopped in because I heard new owners/management and they have been getting good reviews on Ulster Eateries Unfiltered. Ordered garlic knots, large pepperoni pizza with extra pepperoni and additional cupped pepperonis on one half ( yeah, we like pepperoni, I guess) and a small chicken, bacon ranch pie. Garlic knots were nothing impressive, a little garlic salt on top, no infused oil and a few small pieces of fresh garlic scattered under some of the knots, had hoped that garlic was wrapped inside but sadly not, basically pizza dough. Pepperoni was good and the chicken, bacon ranch was lacking much flavour, not sure how’s that possible with bacon and ranch but it was lacking. The crust was decent under the pie but inedible at the end crush but the raccoons and skunks in our back yard scarfed it done. Seems to be the case with most pizza in the area lately with very few exceptions, food was mediocre at best, staff was friendly and fast but we will not be back."