Carlo's Pizza Oven of Holbrook

"Great spot for pizza. Their zeppoles are delicious too. It's our go to when we don't feel like cooking. They seem to always have our order done faster than they say so I've been showing up a few minutes early so I can get it home faster! Awesome staff and great atmosphere if you want to eat in."

"customer service 101- FAILED HERE. I ordered food online, which consists of a very simple order. large pizza half cheese half mushroom. when I got home to enjoy the food, I open it up to half cheese half pepperoni, which is not what I ordered. I called them up immediately, waited way too long to get someone to give me response. I explained to him The order was wrong and I'd like to have the right pizza I paid for. he said bring it in. I was like what, you want me to bring back a pizza in that they messed up on? so they can eat it themselves? I asked what he can do, and I had to force it out of him to please make me the right pizza that I ordered. sounds like this guy was basically rushing me off the phone. I called again 10 minutes later to make sure that the pizza was ready and correct, and the young lady said yes. upon arrival to get the food, this bald guy gave me the pizza, I opened up to reassure that it was right one he says it's mushroom in there. I said politely thank you for fixing that, and he turned his head and said nothing to me. no apologies no accountability. The food wasn't even that great after all. This place lost my business for good. anyone in the Holbrook area, you better off going to Mama Lombardi's. Way better food, and more courteous professional service."

"I got a regular slice of pizza, and it cost $4.30..... not worth it. Family owned it may be, but nothing Family about it. FYI, when I see prices way above the normal, chances are the business is looking to close, sell, or think their food is above par. I would not recommend this establishment to anyone. I travel all over Long Island, and this was my first time eating here."

"I don't know where to begin. First off parking in the lot is crazy. We ordered six knots, mozzarella sticks and a large pie. Knots and sticks were good. Pie had some flavor but seemed undercooked for our liking. The prices are absolutely insane and don't match the prices online. 26 bucks for a plain cheese pie is ridiculous and definitely not worth the price. There are much better pizza places around that you don't need to take a loan out or sell your first born child to go to."

"We ordered on Uber eats on Saturday around 730 pm. We got mozzarella sticks and a Margherita pie. Initially tried to get zeppolis instead of the mozzarella sticks but they did not have any available, I guess because it was later in the evening. The food came quickly. It was very good and we will order from her again. Would recommend."