Mama J's on Main Pizza & More

"Last Saturday we had dinner here with some friends. I had heard they have been very busy lately so I called ahead and reserved a table. The gentleman who took my call asked if we would like to order an appetizer to have ready for us on our arrival, which I thought was a brilliant idea but as we had never been before we held off on this offer. It has an older diner feel to it and it looks like they get a lot of take out or delivery calls which made me a little skeptical about dining in but turns out I was worried for nothing. The service and food were great. Our party of four felt comfortable and well taken care of. So glad we decided to take the little drive over to Nyssa to try Mama J's out. We will definitely be back!"

"Food was very good at a more then fair price. Nothing tasted frozen or cheap quality. Building itself is a little run down and some of the boothes are in disrepair but dont let that deter you. I had burger and asked for it very well done. They delivered happily. My husband had their version of a supreme pizza. The crust was soft and fluffy with a crisp crunchy bottom. They are definitely not stingy with the toppings unlike some chain restraunts. And they have good ranch which is inportant in a pizza place lol. Its a bit of a drive but sort of a hidden gem."

"Stop in for the first time, we had finger steaks and the first go around was extremely greasy; but a 5 star for the owner noticing us patting off the grease! He came back with us not saying a word and brought us a fresh plate of finger steaks and chips. They were great! But I don’t like to leave negative reviews; but as a small business owner you can not fix something you do not k ow. I had heard good things about the pizza; so order a few to go! But for the PIZZA.. it was the worst pizza I have ever had in my life… there was very very little sauce, might as well say no cheese and barely any toppings. The crust was literally like a piece of cardboard. Sorry to leave this review, as I know it was a new cook; but this quality of pizza is not acceptable in my books. To be 100% honest with you I don’t know if I will ever order the pizza again. It was a huge disappointment. No cheese on a pizza and a scoff of sauce. Hope it gets better as the pictures I see on the reviews about you r pizza.. looks like good pizza bjt here is a picture of what we received!"

"We ordered the Classic Burger & Fries, Cheesesteak w/ grilled onions & CheezeWiz with Onion Rings on the side, & Bone-in Smokehouse BBQ wings. The burger was big and tasty. Personal preference would have more seasoning on the beef. Cheesesteak was very good! Fries were fresh cut. Fries & Onion rings were a little over-cooked for our tastes but still tasted good. The house fry sauce was good! The Chicken wings were large and flavorful. My call in order was ready in 20 minutes. Parking is a bit difficult to navigate due to the private homes on either side of the restaurant having no parking signs posted but once I found a spot I was in & out quick enough. Staff were pleasant on the phone and in getting my order rang up and to me. Looking forward to trying more menu items."