Black Cat Pizzeria

"I know they have great reviews, maybe we were just there on an off night. After a little time we may give them another try. We walked in and there were three employees at the counter, one on the phone taking an order and it looked like a manager and another employee standing a little ways down the counter having a counseling session that should have been taken place in the back but we waited for a while before someone even greeted us! We waited for the employee taking the order on the phone to finish before anyone acknowledged us. The manager and the other employee were so engrossed in their conversation that they did not even acknowledge our presence. Pretty sad way to start off a first impression to a new customer who has never been there before. So we ordered our pizza and they brought it out and it was less than spectacular. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza looked good however it was almost burnt on the bottom, doughy and gooey in the middle. We were not happy and I asked if this was normal and the response was "yeah that looks about right". They did not seem to concerned that we weren't happy. So apparently if you like pizza that's burnt on the bottom and still dough underneath the toppings and this is the place for you. Because according to them that's about right. Surely with all the positive reviews this can't be the norm for this pizza kitchen, so after a little while we'll go back and give it another go just because of its reputation. But if this had been my first visit offhand without any prior expectations I can tell you that we wouldn't bother to go back again."

"Excellent food and service. We ordered the Pesto Stix and a Hawaiian Pizza. Both were delicious. The sweet chili sauce on the pizza makes it perfect!"

"Very friendly, pizza is really good and fresh Mushrooms and all ingredients but I always get sausage pepperoni and mushrooms on first pizza. Well priced too."

"This was a unique place to visit, and the pizza and salads were quite good. It comes freshly baked by the slice or different sizes in a thin crust. We ordered a slice of white pizza and asked for meatballs as the topping, and it was yummy. We also tried a pepperoni and sausage slice and lastly a Supreme slice."

"August 2022. First time here and we were all pleasantly surprised. Large pizzas are really large, the three of us had half a pizza left. Very flavorful pizza with good crust too. We've been back one time since for to-go pizza and it was just as good. Would have been 5 stars but an employee was walking around drinking a beer. He may have just got off shift or something, but still just didn't seem quite right."