Jacks Surf & Turf 504 Millburn Avenue, Millburn, NJ 07078

"Did a pick up of a lobster bisque for lunch. The bisque was delicious but I was extremely disappointed that the lobster in it was imitation lobster. What a let down especially since they have all these fresh lobsters in tanks. Charging $2 for extra tiny amount of imitation meat is robbery. Buyer beware. May as well get it with no meat added and it would be better. Thank you for the reply but I have a picture of the lobster I got on the side and it is 100% imitation. The taste and texture was nothing like real lobster. The even sized shreds are a dead giveaway. The bisque was wonderful just letting people know I didn’t care for what you put in it. I hope to come back and try again. Maybe just get the “lobster” on the side next time."

"We were here two weeks in a row. I think we like it. The first time my husband had a lobster and it was very good. This week I found my favorite place for fish tacos."

"Wow!! One of the best experiences I've ever had catering for my film crew!! I spoke with Koko directly who was unbelievably kind and knowledgable, and went above and beyond to ensure my crew and I were happy and well-fed. Even when going to pickup the food, he helped me carry everything out to my vehicle as it was a large order. As aforementioned, I placed a large catering order on a Monday morning and Koko and the team made it happen! I discovered Jack's Surf and Turf at a recent event and saw online that they also had non-seafood options, as we had a few seafood allergies/aversions on set. When I called to place the order, Koko was super accommodating and assured me I could feed all of the crew with vegetarian and meat options—and I did! Everything was cooked and prepared to perfection. The tacos were FULL and loaded with flavor (we got chicken and beef), the salads and dressings were delicious, the coleslaw was (and I quote) "some of the best I've had" from some members in the crew, the sliders were gone in seconds, the mac & cheese was flavorful and creamy, and the chicken tenders and fries were a yummy combo. I found the personal touch of my name on all the "thank you" notes on the boxes such a lovely thing to do. Again: above and beyond! My only note for next time is maybe including a hearty vegan option, as I wasn't aware of any on the menu. However, everything else was fantastic and I was able to accommodate the vegan crew member with a salad and fry platter. I believe they're undergoing a rebrand to "Jack's Surf and Turf" and let me tell you right now, their "Turf" is just as incredible as their "Surf", so I'm in full support of this haha! Overall, I was blown away by the service, kindness, flavor, and value, and I don't write this kind of thing about just any place. If you're in the area or ever need to cater for an event, this is your place!! I'll be back!"

"I dined in last week and there was only 2 people inside . It was off hours . The waitress was very nice told her it was my first time and she recommended the clam chowder and lobster roll . So that’s what I did the soup was very tasty only thing was only a few chopped clams mostly potatoes. The Connecticut state a lobster roll was overcooked ! Some pieces of the lobster were ok and others were dried out. I eat seafood 6 days a week and I’m addicted ! I just moved to the area so will give it another try , but different menu items ."

"Lot in the back plus street parking, outside and two floors inside for seating. I had a yelp event here and they compd a lobster roll, which I have to say was pretty good, Maine style, lots of lobster, not too much mayo and the right kind of bread, not a poor hot dog bun like some others. The calamari was good, rings and legs, and the soup in a bowl would have been better but they gave me lobster bisque instead of the New England clam chowder I ordered... Ah well. Next time!"