AJ's Pizza Butler 12 Main Street, Butler, NJ 07405

"First time here, just moved locally a few months ago. We got a couple of regular pizzas and a gluten free pizza. The person taking the order was great, didn't rush me at all even though I'm sure it was busy at 6:30 on a Friday night. The pizzas were ready right on time, pick up was incredibly fast & easy. The pizzas were AMAZING! Best pizza I've had since moving here - I work in lower Manhattan and there's nothing there that compares. The restaurant was very busy, but very clean - staff were friendly - location is great - prices are very good - and the pizzas can't be beat. We're definitely going back!"

"The chicken parm dinners we ordered were as hard as rock to chew you guys over cooked the chicken cutlets. Thought I’d give this place a chance but you didn’t pull through. Probably Won’t be ordering here again."

"i ordered a cheesesteak and it came without cheese. when i called to tell them, the manager told me i was wrong because told me he made it and goes “i personally remember putting cheese on it” but clearly there wasn’t any cheese. so much for the manager doing his job right, i asked them to come through the side to not wake my kid and of course they came through the front and rang the bell. do better management. the customer is always right but clearly not at ajs pizza, go down the street to Danny’s for better service."

"I was there a couple weeks ago. The people were super nice. The food was delicious. Great pizza amd pasta. Sonny was who served us the food. He was funny and even gave me some of his delicious coffee. Will definitely go back next time I'm in New Jersey."

"I have dined/ordered at AJ's pizza in Butler for awhile now, and after being skeptical due to the reviews as of late in regards to their staff and food, I am happy to say, it is still amazing if not more. The women that answer the phones are kind, courteous, respectful and amazingly accommodating. Even as I can hear the multiple phone lines ringing in the background, they never made me feel rushed or less than the next customer. The front desk male employee was nothing but sweet and attentive to our needs as consumers. I would highly recommend this establishment, (even as a picky eater) they have yet to get my order wrong. Props to the staff and new/old owners for training your staff to the highest degree!"