Original Italian Pizza 3412 Waterlick Road, Lynchburg, VA 24502

"OIP has delicious food and an amazing wait staff. They have an affordable and delicious lunch buffet daily, offering a variety of choices, including pizzas, pastas, casseroles, bread sticks, desserts, and a full salad bar. Their Sunday buffet boasts even more offerings. OIP makes the best New York style pizza!"

"Called an order at 5:10 PM said it would be ready in 25 to 30 minutes. Was there to pick it up 30 minutes later and They said it was not ready. Waited an additional 30 minutes, asked again, the waitress looked at the same boxes she looked at previously, had a stricken look on her face and said yes, it was ready. I asked if it had been up there the whole time (knowing it had) and she said “we’ve been busy” Another waitress chimed in saying she was new. No compensation was offered. Rude customer service. Never had this experience at this location before but will definitely not be coming back again. Terrible service, rude staff. We waited an hour for Cold pizza."

"To be fair, all kitchens have “off nights.” We picked up to go orders. My wife got lasagna and I got spaghetti and meatballs. We both ate a few bites of our dinners and threw the rest out. My spaghetti tasted like the water that was used for the noodles was not clean. The sauce was watered down and the meatballs did not appear to look real or taste real. OIP was not like this a year ago. Something’s up. We like to support small local business like OIP. Not the big corporate chains. So decide for yourself."

"Burgers are usually good except the last two times I've eaten here. Burgers smell rancid and buns are slimy and mushy. I took one bite and almost immediately spit it out and chucked this disgusting meal in the trash where it belongs."

"Husband got 2 slices of pizza, said it was pretty good. I got the baked spaghetti and the sauce was way too sweet & was dangerously hot. Tasted like sugar was added to a can of spaghetti Os. The lemonade was very good. Service was great but there was only two tables in use. I did not take the spaghetti home to my dogs. Not a fan at all!!"