Vitale's Pizza Kitchen

"My husband, toddler and I stopped in for lunch while we shopped. Ordered cheese pizza slices with a Caesar salad and a Philly cheese steak with fries. Everything was delicious. We ordered it as take out to come back and pick up after we browsed the stores in the same shopping center. The girl at the counter was nice and the place clean. The food smelled wonderful as we were placing our order."

"Ordered a cheese pie. Way undercooked. Dough was nearly raw. Little heavy on the cheese too. Crust was not bad though!"

"ordered a simple cheese pizza which is pretty much impossible to mess up but somehow it was. shouldve had twice as much cheese and shouldnt be able to see pools of tomato sauce, wont be coming back here"

"I'm an ex-Long Islander, so I know my New York pizza. This place is very close. Excellent crust, great sauce...and I can get sliced meatballs as a topping. Nice! Just wish they had indoor seating."

"Since leaving my last review I decided to try something new so we ordered the Tuscan Chicken Lettuce Wraps, Fried Mozzarella, Stuffed Shells, Pizza and Zeppoli & Gelato and a pizza. The chicken was so dry it literally scratched my mouth and throat. Nothing was "wrapped" there was just a bunch of tomato's and dry chicken on top of wilted lettuce leaves. The stuffed shells were overcooked and pasty and the cheese filling was a runny tasteless mess. The pizza was lukewarm and dry, it had very little sauce and the dough itself seriously lacked flavor. The Zeppoli's were hard, like they had been sitting for awhile or microwaved and the Gelato came prepackaged and was half melted because they put it in the same bag as the other food. It seems with this place the food is hit or miss. The only thing that we ate was the Mozzarella sticks and they were pretty good. To spend $55 on food you have to throw away is shameful and I won't be doing it again! I stand corrected and wanted to make a post to say that Vitale's Pizza Kitchen absolutely redeemed themselves tonight! I had the pleasure of meeting Julie Vitale tonight and she was gracious enough to remake my order from last week. I didn’t know it was their first week and they had an oven down before giving my review. So I was pleased that Julie reached out to me and offered a redo. I can’t say enough good things about the pizzas we got tonight. The crust was perfect, crispy and still remarkably soft on the edges. The sauce was delicious with just the right amount of seasoning and was spread all the way to the top. The cheese covered the entire pizza and had remarkable stretch, flavor and consistency. The desserts are amazing and I’ll even admit, better than mine! We definitely have a new favorite pizza place and I can’t wait to try their pasta dishes and Luli’s cheese bread, my daughter is especially excited about trying their homemade cheese sticks. We will be seeing you Friday Julie and thank you so very much for the wonderful pizza and desserts tonight!"