The 30 Best Specialty pies in New York City, New York

Red Barn Bakery, located at 4 South Astor Street in Irvington, New York, is a charming institution offering a wide variety of traditional, gluten-free, and vegan baked goods. From award-winning pies and tarts to cookies, muffins, and biscotti, Red Barn Bakery has something for everyone. Owner and founder Randell Dodge is dedicated to using the freshest local and organic ingredients to create delicious treats that have been featured in prestigious publications like the New York Times and Martha Stewart Magazine. At Red Barn Bakery, you can find specialty items like the "Gluten Free Vegan Semi-Naked Matcha Cake" and "Fresh Berry Cream Puffs," as well as seasonal favorites such as the "Organic Strawberry Rhubarb Pie" and "Organic Chocolate Pecan Pie." Whether you're in the mood for a French macaron or a dairy-free coconut raspberry rhubarb tart, Red Barn Bakery has you covered.

Wagner's Farm Market is a charming grocery store located at 2672 Lockport Road in Sanborn, New York. This family-owned institution offers a wide selection of fresh produce, locally sourced products, and delicious homemade goods. Customers can shop for farm-fresh fruits and vegetables, baked goods, dairy products, and much more. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Wagner's Farm Market is a beloved destination for those seeking the best in local food and groceries.

Fisher's Farm Market is a charming grocery and supermarket located at 11074 Ridge Road in Medina, New York. This family-owned institution offers a wide variety of fresh produce, locally sourced goods, and homemade products. Customers can enjoy browsing through the aisles filled with farm-fresh fruits and vegetables, delicious baked goods, and specialty items. Fisher's Farm Market prides itself on providing high-quality, seasonal produce and exceptional customer service. Whether you're looking for a quick snack or ingredients for a home-cooked meal, this market has something for everyone. Visit Fisher's Farm Market for a delightful shopping experience that supports local farmers and producers.

Raspberry Farm is a charming and picturesque institution located at 150-15 14th Avenue in New York, United States. As a specialty food and grocery store, we pride ourselves on offering the freshest and most delicious raspberries to our customers. Our supermarket is stocked with a wide variety of raspberry products, including fresh berries, jams, sauces, and baked goods. Whether you're looking to enjoy raspberries on their own or incorporate them into your favorite recipes, Raspberry Farm has everything you need to satisfy your berry cravings. Visit us today and experience the sweet and tangy goodness of raspberries straight from the farm.

European Taste is a charming grocery store located at 876 Ridge Road in Rochester, New York. As the name suggests, this institution specializes in offering a wide array of European delicacies and ingredients. From imported cheeses and cured meats to specialty pastas and sauces, European Taste is a one-stop shop for all your culinary needs. Step inside and immerse yourself in the flavors and aromas of Europe, right here in the United States. Whether you're looking to recreate a traditional dish from your travels or simply want to explore new flavors, European Taste has something for everyone. Come visit us today and experience a taste of Europe in the heart of Rochester.

Youngs Farm is a charming institution located at 91 Hegemans Lane in Glen Head, New York. This family-owned establishment is a one-stop shop for all your bakery, food, grocery, and supermarket needs. With a wide selection of fresh produce, baked goods, and specialty items, Youngs Farm is a favorite destination for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're looking for farm-fresh fruits and vegetables, delicious homemade pies and pastries, or gourmet pantry staples, you'll find it all at Youngs Farm. Come experience the warm hospitality and quality products that have made Youngs Farm a beloved institution in the community.

Located at 21 Broadway Avenue in Fire Island, New York, the Pioneer Market is a one-stop shop for all your grocery needs. From fresh seafood to ice cream, we offer a wide variety of high-quality products to our customers. As the exclusive retailer of Stonewall Kitchen specialty foods and Blue Duck Bakery pies on Fire Island, we take pride in providing top-notch items for our community. Our fresh produce is delivered seven days a week, ensuring that you receive only the best fruits and vegetables available. Whether you're looking for Holland peppers or local Long Island corn, we have you covered. Serving the west end of Fire Island, including Lonelyville, Dunewood, Fair Harbor, Saltaire, and Kismet, the Pioneer Market is your go-to destination for all your grocery needs.

Steven's Deli & Grocery is a beloved neighborhood institution located at 3924 7th Avenue in New York, United States. This bustling store offers a wide variety of fresh produce, pantry staples, and specialty items. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat from the deli counter or stocking up on groceries for the week, Steven's has you covered. With friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere, this store is a go-to destination for all your food and grocery needs.

Sanger Farm & Bakery is a charming institution located at 852 Lockport Street in Youngstown, New York. This beloved bakery and food store offers a wide variety of freshly baked goods, locally sourced produce, and gourmet products. Customers can indulge in delicious pastries, breads, pies, and more, all made with the finest ingredients. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, Sanger Farm & Bakery is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings and support local farmers. Come visit us and experience the taste of homemade goodness!

Organic Berry Farm is a charming establishment located on 108th Street in the bustling city of New York, United States. As a specialty food store, they offer a wide selection of fresh, locally sourced organic berries that are sure to delight your taste buds. From juicy strawberries to plump blueberries, their farm-fresh produce is bursting with flavor and nutrients. Whether you're looking to whip up a delicious smoothie, bake a mouthwatering pie, or simply enjoy a healthy snack, Organic Berry Farm has you covered. Visit their store today and experience the deliciousness of their farm-fresh berries for yourself!

Welcome to La Famosa, Holtsville's premier destination for delicious, authentic cuisine that will transport your taste buds straight to Italy. Conveniently located at 1018 Waverly Ave, our restaurant offers both dine-in and meal delivery services, ensuring you can enjoy our mouth-watering dishes wherever you are. At La Famosa, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to create a wide variety of delectable dishes. Whether you're craving a sauceless pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese, or a thin Sicilian crust brushed with olive oil and garlic, fresh mozzarella, and chunky San Marzano tomato sauce, we've got you covered.

Welcome to Apizza Regionale, your destination for exquisite pizzas that blend the authenticity of true Neapolitan style with the bold flavors of New York. Located at 260 Genesee Street in the heart of Syracuse, New York, we are more than just a restaurant—we are a culinary experience inspired by the rich Italian tradition of regional cooking and seasonality. At Apizza Regionale, we pride ourselves on sourcing the finest ingredients from regional growers and producers in New York State, Italy, and surrounding areas. This commitment to quality and freshness is evident in every bite, making our pizzas a standout choice for food lovers and casual diners alike.

Welcome to McGraw's Small Town Pizzeria, where authentic flavors and a warm, friendly atmosphere come together to create an unforgettable dining experience. Nestled in the heart of McGraw, New York, at 6 Main Street, our restaurant is a beloved local gem that has been serving the community with passion and dedication. At McGraw's Small Town Pizzeria, we take pride in crafting delicious, hand-tossed pizzas using only the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes. Our menu features a wide variety of options to satisfy every palate, from classic Margherita and Pepperoni pizzas to innovative specialty pies that showcase our culinary creativity. We also offer a selection of mouth-watering appetizers, fresh salads, and hearty pasta dishes, ensuring there's something for everyone to enjoy.

Welcome to Cincinnatus Home Center, your one-stop destination for all your home improvement, grocery, and bakery needs in Cincinnatus, New York. Conveniently located at 2752 State Route 26, we pride ourselves on offering an extensive range of products and services designed to meet the diverse needs of our community. Whether you're a DIY enthusiast or a professional contractor, you'll find everything you need in our comprehensive selection of lumber and building materials, including framing lumber, engineered wood products, and more. Our hardware store is stocked with a wide array of tools and supplies, from hand and power tools to plumbing and electrical essentials. Explore our paint department featuring Do-It-Best and Cabot paints, perfect for any interior or exterior project.

Welcome to Adriano's Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, handcrafted pizzas in Johnson City, New York. Conveniently located at 263 Floral Avenue, our family-owned restaurant is dedicated to serving the local community with mouthwatering flavors and exceptional service. At Adriano's Pizza, we take pride in using only the freshest ingredients to create our signature pizzas, each bursting with authentic taste and quality. Our diverse menu offers something for everyone, from classic favorites like Margherita and Pepperoni to unique specialty pies that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. In addition to our pizzas, we also offer a variety of appetizers, salads, pasta dishes, and desserts to complete your dining experience.

Welcome to Josie's Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, handcrafted pizzas in Alexandria Bay, New York. Located at 19 Church Street, Josie's Pizza is a beloved local eatery known for its warm, welcoming atmosphere and mouth-watering menu. Our pizzas are crafted with the freshest ingredients, ensuring every bite is a burst of flavor. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita, a hearty Meat Lovers, or a creative specialty pizza, we've got something to satisfy every craving. Beyond pizzas, we offer a variety of salads, appetizers, and desserts to complement your meal. At Josie's Pizza, we pride ourselves on excellent service, a cozy dining experience, and a commitment to quality. Join us for a delightful meal with family and friends, or take advantage of our convenient take-out options. We look forward to serving you at Josie's Pizza, where every slice is made with love!

Welcome to Fattie G’s Pizzeria, your new favorite spot for delicious and unique culinary creations in Angola, New York! Conveniently located at 8746 Erie Road, we pride ourselves on offering an exciting twist on traditional pizzeria fare. Our menu is crafted with the freshest ingredients and features innovative dishes that you won’t find anywhere else. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or eager to try something new, Fattie G’s Pizzeria has something for everyone. Join us for a memorable dining experience that celebrates community and creativity, one bite at a time. Come and discover what makes us a standout choice in the local food scene!

Welcome to Hunt Brothers Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious and satisfying pizzas in New York, 14075. As a local favorite, we take pride in serving our community with a delightful array of mouth-watering pizzas and more. Our restaurant is all about quality, flavor, and a welcoming atmosphere where friends and family can come together to enjoy great food. At Hunt Brothers Pizza, we offer a diverse menu that caters to all taste preferences. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni, a veggie-loaded masterpiece, or a unique specialty pizza, we have something to please every palate. Our pizzas are crafted with the freshest ingredients, ensuring every bite is bursting with flavor.

Welcome to Big Mac Pizza, your ultimate destination for delicious and unique pizza creations in North Tonawanda, New York! Conveniently located at 452 Oliver Street, our restaurant is a haven for food lovers who crave a perfect blend of flavor, quality, and innovation. At Big Mac Pizza, we pride ourselves on crafting pizzas that are not only mouthwateringly delicious but also memorable. Our menu features a wide variety of options, from classic favorites to inventive specialties that will tantalize your taste buds. Every pizza is made with the freshest ingredients and our signature dough, ensuring a delightful experience in every bite.

Welcome to Barbie-Pierogi! Located at 12 Howard Street, Silver Creek, New York, Barbie-Pierogi is your go-to destination for delicious, homemade pierogi with a twist. Founded by Barbara and Mark Lancaster, who transitioned from a combined 50 years in the wine industry to pursue Barbara's lifelong passion for making pierogi, our business is dedicated to bringing you the finest pierogi experience.

Welcome to Mama’s Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, handcrafted pizzas in the heart of Sherman, New York. Nestled at 111 West Main Street, our cozy restaurant is a beloved local gem known for its warm atmosphere and mouthwatering menu. At Mama’s Pizza, we take pride in using only the freshest ingredients to create a variety of classic and innovative pizzas that cater to all taste buds. Whether you're a fan of the traditional Margherita or looking to try something new like our specialty gourmet pies, we have something for everyone. Beyond pizzas, our menu also features a selection of savory sides, fresh salads, and delectable desserts to complement your meal. Perfect for family dinners, casual lunches, or a quick bite with friends, Mama’s Pizza offers a welcoming environment where you can enjoy great food and friendly service. Come visit us and experience the flavors that have made us a favorite in the community. We look forward to serving you soon!

Welcome to El Palacio de Las Empanadas, your go-to destination for authentic and delicious empanadas in the heart of Queens, New York! Conveniently located at 53-02 108th Street, our vibrant eatery offers a delightful culinary experience that brings the rich flavors of Latin America right to your plate. Whether you're looking to dine in, grab a quick meal on the go, or enjoy the convenience of meal delivery, we have you covered. At El Palacio de Las Empanadas, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to create a wide variety of empanadas that cater to every taste bud. From classic beef and chicken to innovative vegetarian options, our menu is designed to satisfy both traditional and adventurous palates. Each empanada is handcrafted with love and care, ensuring a perfect blend of taste and texture in every bite.

Welcome to Pizza Roma, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian pizza right in the heart of Brooklyn! Conveniently located at 175 Nassau Avenue, Brooklyn, New York 11222, we pride ourselves on serving up a taste of Italy with every slice. Our menu features a wide variety of mouth-watering pizzas, crafted with the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes that have been passed down through generations. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita, a hearty Meat Lover's, or a unique specialty pie, Pizza Roma has something to satisfy every palate. In addition to our signature pizzas, we offer a selection of appetizers, salads, and desserts to complete your meal.

Welcome to Brick Oven Pizza, your go-to destination for authentic, mouth-watering pizza in the heart of Queens, New York. Conveniently located at 10721 Metropolitan Avenue, our restaurant is a beloved local gem where tradition meets taste. At Brick Oven Pizza, we pride ourselves on crafting delicious pizzas using only the freshest ingredients and time-honored recipes. Our signature brick oven imparts a unique, crispy texture and rich flavor to every pie, ensuring a delightful dining experience. Beyond our classic and specialty pizzas, we offer a diverse menu featuring fresh salads, hearty pastas, and savory appetizers, all made with the same commitment to quality. Whether you're dining in with family and friends, picking up a quick takeout, or getting your meal delivered, Brick Oven Pizza promises exceptional service and a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Join us and discover why we're a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Come savor the taste of tradition at Brick Oven Pizza, where every bite feels like home.

Welcome to Milk N Honey, your go-to destination for delicious and satisfying vegetarian meals in the heart of Brooklyn! Located at 5013 10th Avenue, Brooklyn, New York 11219, we offer a delightful array of food options, whether you're looking for meal delivery, takeaway, or a cozy sit-down experience in our restaurant. At Milk N Honey, we pride ourselves on our diverse menu that caters to every taste. Indulge in our signature Vegetarian Burger topped with mozzarella cheese and our specialty sauce, or savor the flavors of our tuna fish salad sub, packed with fresh veggies. Our golden-brown French fries, seasoned to perfection, are the perfect complement to any meal.

Welcome to DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake, your ultimate culinary destination in Staten Island, New York! Nestled at 977 Victory Boulevard, our restaurant offers a delightful blend of tradition and innovation, bringing you an unforgettable dining experience. Specializing in artisanal pizzas and gourmet dishes, our menu is crafted with the freshest ingredients and a passion for flavor. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita or an adventurous specialty pie, our wood-fired ovens ensure each pizza is baked to perfection. Beyond pizza, explore our selection of mouth-watering appetizers, fresh salads, and delectable desserts, all designed to satisfy your taste buds. Join us at DOUGH by Licastri Silver Lake, where every meal is a celebration of taste, quality, and community spirit. We look forward to welcoming you!

Welcome to Seany Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, handcrafted pizzas in the heart of Queens, New York. Located at 97-01 Shore Front Parkway, just a stone's throw away from the beautiful Rockaway Beach, we pride ourselves on serving mouth-watering pizzas made from the freshest ingredients. At Seany Pizza, we believe in delivering an exceptional dining experience, whether you're grabbing a quick slice on the go or enjoying a leisurely meal with family and friends. Our menu features a wide variety of classic and gourmet pizzas, each crafted with love and attention to detail. From traditional Margherita and Pepperoni to our unique specialty pies, there's something to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to Anita’s Deli & Restaurant, your neighborhood destination for delicious and freshly prepared meals in East Northport, New York. Located at 36 Laurel Road, our family-owned establishment has been serving the community with a passion for quality food and warm hospitality. At Anita’s, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that caters to all tastes. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely meal with friends and family, you'll find a wide selection of deli sandwiches, hearty entrees, and homemade specialties crafted with the finest ingredients. Our cozy and inviting atmosphere is perfect for any occasion, from casual lunches to intimate dinners.

Welcome to Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria! Nestled in the heart of Farmingville, New York, Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria is your go-to destination for authentic and mouth-watering Italian cuisine. Located at 374 Mooney Pond Road, our family-friendly restaurant offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere where you can enjoy a delectable dining experience with loved ones.

Welcome to Yaphank Community Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, handcrafted pizzas in the heart of Yaphank, New York. Conveniently located on Yaphank Avenue, we pride ourselves on serving the finest quality pizzas, crafted with the freshest ingredients and a passion for flavor. At Yaphank Community Pizza, we offer a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for family gatherings, casual dinners, or a quick meal on-the-go. Our extensive menu features a variety of classic and specialty pizzas, alongside a selection of mouth-watering appetizers, salads, and desserts to satisfy every palate.