TOP 30 Best Pie selection in New York

Welcome to Angelina's Pizza, a beloved culinary gem located at 1191 Grundy Avenue, Holbrook, New York. As a staple in the community, we invite you to experience the best pizza Holbrook has to offer. Our menu is brimming with a diverse selection of mouth-watering pizzas, savory pastas, and hearty sandwiches, each crafted with the freshest ingredients to satisfy your cravings and expand your culinary horizons. At Angelina's Pizza, we pride ourselves on offering a wide array of delicious options. From classic favorites like chicken parm, sausage parm, and meatball parm, to our unique creations such as the thin crust pie with mozzarella cheese and a garlic plum tomato sauce, there's something for everyone. For those seeking a hearty meal, try our deep dish pie topped with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted peppers, and a drizzle of olive oil.

Welcome to Beach Bakery & Grand Cafe Nestled in the heart of Westhampton Beach, New York, Beach Bakery & Grand Cafe is your go-to destination for delightful culinary experiences. Located at 112 Main Street, we proudly serve as a bakery, restaurant, and store, offering a variety of delicious treats and hearty meals for all occasions.

Welcome to Crust Around The Corner, East Moriches' beloved pizza haven, where culinary creativity meets classic flavors! Nestled at 345 Montauk Highway E, East Moriches, New York, our restaurant is a cornerstone of delicious dining and community spirit. Known for our innovative pizza creations, we invite you to explore a menu brimming with delightful options, from the classic cheese pizza to our signature "East Moriches style" pizza—a crispy cheese crust topped with our family's special Grandma sauce. Indulge in our unique offerings like the Chicken Cutlet Ranch Pizza with bacon bits or the fiery Spicy BBQ Chicken Pizza. For those seeking a veggie delight, our thin square Grandma pizza, topped with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil, is a must-try. We also cater to gluten-free preferences with our famous homemade 9" personal pies crafted with cauliflower crust.

Welcome to Dave's Diner, your go-to destination for delicious comfort food in the heart of Utica, New York. Conveniently located at 2251 New York 5, our charming diner offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can enjoy a delightful meal with family and friends. At Dave's Diner, we pride ourselves on serving classic American dishes made from the freshest ingredients. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a cozy dinner, our diverse menu has something for everyone. From fluffy pancakes and savory omelets to juicy burgers and homemade pies, each dish is crafted with care and passion. In addition to our dine-in experience, we also offer a selection of specialty products available for purchase in our store, allowing you to take a taste of Dave's home with you. Join us at Dave's Diner and discover why we're a beloved staple in the Utica community. We look forward to welcoming you soon!

Welcome to Tony's Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic pizza in the heart of Herkimer, New York. Conveniently located at 435 Mohawk Street, Tony's Pizzeria has been serving the community with mouth-watering pizzas, delectable pastas, and a wide variety of Italian favorites. Our passion for quality ingredients and traditional recipes ensures that every bite is a delightful experience. At Tony's Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for family gatherings, casual dinners, or quick takeout. Our menu caters to all tastes, featuring classic and specialty pizzas, fresh salads, savory appetizers, and sumptuous desserts. We also offer a selection of gluten-free and vegetarian options to accommodate diverse dietary preferences.

Welcome to Bread House, your neighborhood bakery located at 1718 Jerome Avenue, Brooklyn, New York. At Bread House, we are passionate about bringing the freshest and most delicious baked goods to our community. Our bakery is renowned for its warm, inviting atmosphere and dedication to quality. Every day, our skilled bakers craft a wide variety of breads, pastries, and specialty items using the finest ingredients. From crusty baguettes and soft, buttery croissants to delectable cakes and cookies, we offer something to satisfy every palate. Whether you're stopping by for your morning coffee and a pastry, picking up a loaf of artisan bread for dinner, or ordering a custom cake for a special occasion, Bread House is here to serve you with a smile.

Welcome to Rolling Pin, your go-to bakery and food store located in the heart of Setauket-East Setauket, New York. Situated at 1387 New York 25A, our charming bakery is a haven for those who appreciate the art of baking and the taste of freshly crafted delights. At Rolling Pin, we pride ourselves on offering a wide selection of mouth-watering baked goods, from classic breads and pastries to custom cakes and seasonal treats, all made with the finest ingredients and a passion for flavor. Whether you're stopping by for your morning coffee and a croissant, picking up a loaf of artisan bread for dinner, or ordering a special cake for a celebration, our friendly staff is dedicated to providing you with exceptional service and a delightful experience. We invite you to explore our store, savor our creations, and become a part of our community of food lovers. Come visit Rolling Pin today and discover the perfect blend of tradition and innovation in every bite.

High Falls Pizzeria & Taphouse is a cozy restaurant located in the heart of Philmont, New York. Situated at 94 Main Street, this institution offers a unique dining experience where delicious pizzas and a wide selection of craft beers come together. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni pizza or want to try one of their specialty pies, you'll find something to satisfy your cravings. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, High Falls Pizzeria & Taphouse is the perfect spot to enjoy a meal with friends and family. Come and experience their mouthwatering pizzas and refreshing beers for yourself!

Amore Pizza Scarsdale, located at 1479 Weaver Street in Scarsdale, New York, has been proudly serving Westchester for nearly two decades. Specializing in seasonal pies following both New and Old World styles, Amore Pizza offers a delicious selection of Italian food and pizza. Whether you're looking for a quick meal delivery or a sit-down restaurant experience, Amore Pizza is dedicated to providing top-notch service and mouthwatering dishes. Customers rave about the quality of the food and the enjoyable dining experience that keeps them coming back for more.

The Little Pizza Shop is a cozy restaurant located at 618 Lapham Mills Road in Peru, New York. Known for its delicious pizzas and friendly service, this eatery is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a menu featuring a variety of toppings and specialty pies, The Little Pizza Shop offers something for everyone. Whether you're dining in or taking out, you can expect fresh, hot pizza made with quality ingredients. Come experience the charm of this neighborhood pizzeria for yourself!

Pronto Pizza is a popular eatery located at 13 Greenfield Road in Woodridge, New York, United States. This bustling restaurant is known for its delicious pizzas, made with fresh ingredients and prepared to perfection. Whether you're looking for a classic pepperoni pie or a specialty gourmet pizza, Pronto Pizza has something for everyone. In addition to their mouthwatering pizzas, they also offer a variety of other Italian dishes, such as pasta, salads, and sandwiches. With friendly staff and a cozy atmosphere, Pronto Pizza is the perfect spot to grab a bite to eat with friends and family.

Charlotte's Tea Room, located at 15 Oakland Avenue in Warwick, New York, offers a unique dining experience that combines traditional English cuisine with American favorites. Founded by Joanne, a former set designer and food stylist, Charlotte's is not your typical tea room. With an ever-evolving menu featuring dishes like Chicken Pot Pie, Quiche of the Day, and Charlotte's Signature Salads, guests can enjoy a leisurely meal without the distractions of wifi or television. Indulge in a selection of hot teas, coffees, sodas, and seasonal desserts, including freshly baked scones. Join our mailing list to stay informed about menu changes and special events. Come to Charlotte's Tea Room to eat, relax, and dream with us.

Essex Pizza, located at 123 Essex Street in New York, offers a wide variety of delicious pizza options to satisfy your cravings. From classic margherita to unique combinations like BBQ chicken and buffalo chicken, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Support local businesses by trying the best pizza in New York, as recommended by residents. With fresh ingredients like chicken, mozzarella cheese, and homemade marinara sauce, each pie is bursting with flavor. Enjoy the convenience of curbside pickup and pay by credit card for a hassle-free experience. Indulge in a slice of New York's finest at Essex Pizza today!

Justino's Pizzeria, located at 879 9th Avenue in New York, offers a wide variety of delicious specialties that you won't find anywhere else. From classic cheese pies to unique combinations like fresh mozzarella with basil and romano cheese, Justino's has something for everyone. In addition to their mouthwatering pizzas, they also offer a selection of salads, heroes, pasta dishes, and appetizers like mozzarella sticks and buffalo wings. Whether you're dining in, ordering delivery, or picking up curbside, Justino's is a convenient and tasty choice. With regular deals and multiple locations, Justino's Pizzeria is a top choice for pizza lovers in New York City. So come on down and experience the best pizza that New York has to offer at Justino's Pizzeria.

Inwood Pizza, located at 179 Sherman Avenue in New York, offers a delicious selection of hand-tossed pizzas made with fresh ingredients. Owned by native Inwood resident Robert Caba, the pizzeria serves up a variety of mouthwatering pies including the signature Grandma pizza, topped with fresh mozzarella, basil, and homemade tomato sauce. In addition to pizzas, Inwood Pizza also offers a Family Special, beef patties, wings, and a variety of sauces to choose from. With options like ham and salami sandwiches, calzones, burgers, pasta, and more, there's something for everyone at Inwood Pizza. Don't forget to take advantage of their online ordering for a 5% discount on every order!

Tartina is a charming bar and restaurant located at 1034 Amsterdam Avenue in the heart of New York City. This cozy establishment offers a wide range of delicious food and drinks, perfect for a casual meal or a night out with friends. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, Tartina is the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a meal in the bustling city. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a leisurely dinner, Tartina has something for everyone. Come and experience the delicious cuisine and welcoming ambiance at Tartina today!

Pizza On The Run is a popular restaurant located at 1627 Mermaid Avenue in New York, United States. Specializing in delicious pizza and other Italian dishes, Pizza On The Run offers convenient meal delivery services for customers on the go. With a wide selection of toppings and flavors to choose from, this eatery is the perfect choice for a quick and satisfying meal. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni pizza or a specialty pie, Pizza On The Run has something for everyone. Come visit us today and taste the difference!

Located in the heart of New York City, P. McDaid’s Irish Pub is a traditional bar serving up delicious Irish cuisine inspired by generations of home cooking. Our menu is carefully curated with the finest ingredients sourced with pride. Whether you're in the mood for classic fish and chips or a hearty shepherd's pie, we have something for everyone to enjoy. At P. McDaid’s Irish Pub, we believe that good food should be shared with good company. That's why our cozy pub hall is the perfect place to gather with friends and family. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, you'll feel right at home as you sip on a pint of Guinness or sample one of our signature cocktails.

Jack Doyle's is a popular bar and restaurant located at 240 West 35th Street in New York City. Since 2012, they have been providing friendly, fast, and attentive service to their customers. Situated in the heart of Manhattan, Jack Doyle's is just steps away from iconic attractions such as Madison Square Garden, the Empire State Building, Macy's, and Times Square. Whether you're looking to catch a game or host a special event, Jack Doyle's has got you covered. They offer a wide range of delicious food options, from nachos and Shepard's pie to bangers and mash and chicken pot pie. The friendly staff and great service make for an enjoyable dining experience.

Irish Haven is a cozy and welcoming bar and restaurant located at 5721 4th Avenue in New York, United States. Known for its authentic Irish atmosphere and delicious food, this institution is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a wide selection of drinks, traditional Irish fare, and friendly staff, Irish Haven is the perfect spot to relax with friends or enjoy a hearty meal. Whether you're looking for a pint of Guinness or a plate of shepherd's pie, Irish Haven has something for everyone. Come and experience the warmth and charm of this beloved establishment in the heart of Brooklyn.

Slattery's Midtown Pub is a popular bar and restaurant located at 8 East 36th Street in New York City, USA. Catering to an after-work and neighborhood crowd, this establishment is the ideal spot for happy hour, a quick bite, or a sit-down meal. With 25 HD TVs scattered throughout the venue, sports fans will never miss a game. Whether you're a Miami Dolphins or New York Rangers fan, Slattery's has got you covered. In addition to sports, Slattery's menu features pub favorites such as burgers, wraps, sandwiches, wings, salads, and traditional entrees like pot pies and fish and chips. On weekends, guests can enjoy a full Irish breakfast. The Empire room is available for private events, with options to rent out the entire space or just a section. Party packages are available, and cash bar options can be arranged depending on the date.

Located at 160 Pearl Street in New York, The Full Shilling is a traditional Irish bar and restaurant that brings a taste of old-world charm to the bustling Wall Street area. The interior bar, which is over a century old and was shipped directly from a pub in Belfast, adds to the authentic atmosphere of this popular establishment. Patrons flock to The Full Shilling during lunch and after work on weekdays to enjoy a hearty menu featuring classic dishes such as beer-battered fish and chips, bangers and mash, and shepherd's pie. With seventeen draft beers to choose from, guests can pair their meal with the perfect brew.

Jones Wood Foundry is a cozy and authentic British pub located in the heart of New York City. Founded with a desire to bring a taste of England to the Big Apple, we have been serving up classic British dishes and cask ales for over a decade. Our menu features traditional recipes that have been passed down for generations, including savory pies, Fish & Chips, and Scotch Eggs. In addition to British fare, we also offer French-inspired dishes such as Onion Soup Gratinée and Boeuf Bourguignon, all prepared by our classically trained chef and founder, Jason Hicks. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a place to watch a soccer game with friends, Jones Wood Foundry provides a warm and convivial atmosphere. Our bar is stocked with a wide selection of imported British beers, craft beers, ciders, and wines to complement your meal. We are open for lunch, dinner, and brunch, with indoor and outdoor seating available. Private dining, takeout, and delivery options are also offered for those on the Upper East Side of NYC. Join us at Jones Wood Foundry for a taste of England in the heart of New York City.

Josie's Little Pizzeria is a cozy and inviting restaurant located on Main Street in Canton, New York. Specializing in delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine, this charming eatery offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere for guests to enjoy a casual dining experience. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni pizza or a hearty pasta dish, Josie's Little Pizzeria has something to satisfy all cravings. Stop by and indulge in their mouthwatering menu selections at this popular local spot.

Pavone's Pizza & Eatery, located at 5781 Bridge Street in East Syracuse, New York, is a beloved institution offering a wide variety of delicious Italian cuisine. Since 1950, we have been serving up authentic New York-style pizza and pasta dishes to the residents of Onondaga County. Our menu features a range of options, from classic pies to Sicilian and Neapolitan specialties. In addition to our mouth-watering pizzas, we also offer a selection of Italian specialties, pasta dishes, hearty entrees, fresh salads, sandwiches, and delectable desserts. Whether you're in the mood for a traditional meal or something more unique, Pavone's Pizza has something for everyone. Our secret to great taste lies in our fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes. You can dine in at our cozy restaurant or order for pickup or delivery through Slice. Join us for lunch or dinner and experience the flavors of authentic Italian cuisine at Pavone's Pizza & Eatery.

New York Pizzeria is a popular restaurant located at 200 South Peterboro Street in Canastota, New York. Known for its delicious and authentic New York-style pizzas, this institution offers a wide variety of toppings and specialty pies to satisfy every craving. In addition to their mouthwatering pizzas, New York Pizzeria also serves up a selection of appetizers, salads, and pasta dishes. Whether you dine in, take out, or opt for their convenient meal delivery service, you can always count on New York Pizzeria for a satisfying and flavorful meal.

The Village Pizza & Pints is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 14 Pierce Avenue in Hamburg, New York. Specializing in delicious pizzas and a wide selection of craft beers on tap, this establishment offers a casual and laid-back dining experience for guests to enjoy. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a place to unwind with friends over a pint, The Village Pizza & Pints is the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings. With friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, this eatery is a must-visit for anyone in the area.

Picasso's Pizza is a popular food establishment located at 4154 McKinley Parkway in Blasdell, New York. This restaurant specializes in delicious pizza and offers convenient meal delivery and takeaway services. With a menu featuring a variety of toppings and specialty pies, Picasso's Pizza is a go-to spot for satisfying your pizza cravings. Whether you're dining in or enjoying a meal at home, this establishment is sure to impress with its tasty offerings and friendly service.

Mister Submarine is a popular food institution located at 1977 South Park Avenue in Buffalo, New York. We specialize in meal delivery, takeaway, and dining in our restaurant. Our menu features delicious submarine sandwiches made with only the best deli meats and freshest produce, all cut on site daily. We also offer fresh homemade pizza with our great pizza sauce. Please note that all submarines with a * next to them do not come with lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. However, our regular subs come with these toppings, and you can choose from a variety of other ingredients to customize your meal. We also offer chicken fingers, steak cut fries, and a selection of sauces for dipping.

Renna's Pizza is a popular restaurant located at 400 North Union Street in Olean, New York. Known for serving some of the best food in the area, Renna's is a local favorite for delicious and hearty meals. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pizza pie or want to create your own masterpiece, Renna's has a wide selection of toppings to choose from. In addition to pizza, they also offer dinners, desserts, sandwiches, wings, and authentic Italian gelato. On Fridays, don't miss out on their affordable and tasty specials. You can dine in at the friendly and welcoming atmosphere of Renna's or order their food for pickup through Slice. Come visit Renna's Pizza and experience the gold standard of pizza for yourself!