TOP 10 Italian food made from scratch in New York

OIP-Original Italian Pizza is a beloved restaurant located at 489 James Street in Syracuse, New York. Known for its authentic Italian cuisine and delicious pizzas, OIP offers a wide variety of meal options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Our menu features traditional Italian dishes, mouthwatering pizzas, and fresh salads made with the finest ingredients. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a family dinner, OIP-Original Italian Pizza is the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings for delicious Italian food. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, you'll feel right at home at OIP. Come visit us today and experience the taste of Italy right here in Syracuse!

L’uccello Pizza & Italian Fare is a charming Italian restaurant located at 112 Broadway in Greenlawn, New York. Our family-owned establishment is dedicated to serving up delicious Italian dishes made from scratch, including classic appetizers, entrees, and creative pizzas made with fresh, local ingredients. Whether you're dining in or taking out, we offer a warm and welcoming atmosphere for you to enjoy a traditional Italian meal or a fun night out with friends. Come visit us today and experience the passion and love we put into every dish at L’uccello Pizza & Italian Fare.

Pizza Place & Trattoria II is a family-owned restaurant located at 35 Main Street in Brewster, New York. Our goal is to provide our customers with top-quality gourmet food for eat-in, take-out, or delivery right to your doorsteps. With almost three decades of experience, customer satisfaction is our main priority. Whether you're craving a classic pizza or traditional Italian dish, we have something for everyone. Feel free to reach out to us at PizzaPlaceBrewster@gmail.com with any questions or inquiries.

Old Stone Trattoria is a charming Italian restaurant located at 425 King Street in the heart of Chappaqua, New York. This cozy eatery offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for enjoying a delicious meal with family and friends. The menu features traditional Italian dishes made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, including homemade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and decadent desserts. With its rustic decor and friendly staff, Old Stone Trattoria is the perfect spot for a memorable dining experience in Chappaqua.

Located at 13550 Main Road in Mattituck, New York, aMano is a charming Italian restaurant and bar that offers a taste of Tuscany on the North Fork. Opened in 2008 by Adam Lovett and Tom Schaudel, aMano specializes in wood oven-fired pizza and pasta made with local ingredients sourced from nearby farms and the bay. The menu features a variety of Italian-inspired appetizers and entrees, all paired with a selection of wines from Long Island and Italy. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a special dining experience, aMano offers a cozy atmosphere and delicious dishes that showcase both Old and New World flavors.

Brother's Trattoria is a charming Italian restaurant located at 2540 State Route 55 in Poughquag, New York. Known for its warm and inviting atmosphere, this family-owned establishment offers a delicious menu of traditional Italian dishes made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. From homemade pasta dishes to wood-fired pizzas, Brother's Trattoria is a favorite dining spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner for two or a casual meal with friends and family, Brother's Trattoria is the perfect place to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine in a cozy setting. Come experience the flavors of Italy at Brother's Trattoria!

La Parmigiana is a charming Italian restaurant located at 44-48 New York 27A in Southampton, New York. Known for its authentic Italian cuisine and warm, welcoming atmosphere, La Parmigiana offers a variety of delicious dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Whether you're craving classic pasta dishes, savory seafood entrees, or mouthwatering desserts, La Parmigiana has something to satisfy every appetite. With excellent service and a cozy ambiance, La Parmigiana is the perfect spot for a romantic dinner, family gathering, or special celebration. Come experience the taste of Italy at La Parmigiana in Southampton.

I Love Pizza of Troy is a beloved food institution located at 125 4th Street in Troy, New York, United States. As a restaurant specializing in delicious pizza, they offer a wide variety of mouth-watering options for both dine-in and delivery. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pie or a unique specialty pizza, I Love Pizza of Troy has something for everyone. With their convenient location and excellent service, it's no wonder why locals and visitors alike can't get enough of this tasty eatery.

Trattoria Fortunata is a charming restaurant located at 21 Phila Street in Saratoga Springs, New York. Our menu strikes a perfect balance between traditional and modern dishes, offering something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you're looking for a simple meal or a more complex dish, we have you covered. We are dedicated to providing an inclusive menu that caters to all dietary preferences. You can easily order online for pick-up or delivery through Mealeo, making it convenient to enjoy our delicious food from the comfort of your own home.

Mazza is a charming and cozy restaurant located in Jamestown West, New York, United States. Serving up delicious and authentic cuisine, Mazza is the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or a romantic dinner with a loved one. With a menu filled with mouthwatering dishes and a warm and inviting atmosphere, Mazza is sure to become your new favorite dining destination. Come and experience the flavors of Mazza today!

Labyrinth Press Company is a unique institution located at 12 East 4th Street in Jamestown, New York, United States. This establishment is a cafe, food, restaurant, and store all rolled into one. They offer a diverse menu of eclectic vegetarian and vegan fare, all made from scratch daily. Originally born as a coffee shop, Labyrinth Press Company has since evolved to include a craft beer and wine bar, as well as a full-service restaurant. Their cozy and inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect spot to enjoy a delicious meal or a refreshing drink with friends and family.

John's of Bleecker Street is a legendary Italian restaurant located at 278 Bleecker Street in New York City. Founded by Italian immigrant Giovanni "John" Sasso at the beginning of the 20th century, John's has been serving up delicious coal-fired pizza and classic Italian dishes for over a century. The restaurant originally started on Sullivan Street in Greenwich Village before moving to its current location on Bleecker Street. Known for its authentic and mouthwatering pizza, John's of Bleecker Street has become a staple in the New York dining scene. The pizza is cooked to perfection in a coal-fired brick oven, resulting in a crisp crust, gooey cheese, and flavorful sauce. In addition to pizza, the restaurant also offers a variety of pasta dishes, with the chicken parmigiana being a standout favorite.

Located at 42 East 8th Street in New York, Lunetta Pizza is a popular food institution known for its delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine. The menu offers a variety of options, including classic toppings like fresh mozzarella, plum tomato sauce, basil, and olive oil, as well as unique combinations like spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and fresh tomatoes. For those looking for something lighter, there are salads with vegan cheese and dressings available. Lunetta Pizza also offers catering options for events and gatherings. With a reputation for serving some of the best pizza in New York, Lunetta Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area. Take advantage of their delivery and takeout services, or stop by one of their multiple locations for a delicious and affordable meal. Pay conveniently by credit card and enjoy a satisfying dining experience at Lunetta Pizza.

Macoletta is a trendy and vibrant establishment located at 2815 24th Avenue in New York, United States. This unique institution offers a combination of a bar, restaurant, food, and store all in one convenient location. Guests can enjoy a wide range of delicious food options, refreshing beverages, and a curated selection of products to take home. With a welcoming atmosphere and top-notch service, Macoletta is the perfect place to unwind, socialize, and indulge in a memorable dining experience.

Cucina Fresca, located at 2110 Richmond Road in New York, United States, is a popular food institution known for its delicious pizza and Italian dishes. Their menu includes a variety of options such as penne vodka, garlic knots, grilled chicken paninis, seafood pasta, and more. One of their specialties is the Carmen's Special, which features assorted meats and vegetables in various styles such as round, deep dish, and square pizzas. Customers can also enjoy special deals like the Two Large Cheese Pizzas, 12 Buffalo Wings & 2 Liter Soda Special. Cucina Fresca offers curbside pickup, delivery, and takeout options for convenience. With regular deals and the ability to pay with credit cards, Cucina Fresca is a great choice for a tasty and affordable meal in Staten Island.

Cascarino's is a cozy Italian restaurant located at 121 Hawkins Drive in Montgomery, New York. Known for its authentic Italian cuisine and warm, inviting atmosphere, Cascarino's is a favorite dining destination for locals and visitors alike. From traditional pasta dishes to gourmet pizzas and fresh seafood, the menu at Cascarino's offers something for everyone. Whether you're looking for a romantic date night spot or a place to gather with friends and family, Cascarino's is the perfect choice for a delicious meal in a welcoming setting. Come experience the flavors of Italy at Cascarino's today!

Divino Cucina Italiana is a trendy Italian restaurant located in Hastings-on-Hudson, New York. Our menu features authentic Italian dishes made from scratch using locally sourced ingredients. We strive to support sustainable farming practices while providing our guests with a modern twist on traditional Italian cuisine. At Divino, every guest is treated like family and receives exceptional customer service. Book a table online using the Seven Room widget and enjoy a unique dining experience with us. Stay updated on our latest news, special offers, and events by subscribing to our newsletter. Looking for the perfect gift? Consider purchasing an e-Gift Card for your loved ones or clients. Our Speakeasy is also available for hosting special events for up to 150 guests, including receptions, weddings, and corporate events. Let us customize your event to create an unforgettable experience at Divino Cucina Italiana.

Antonio's Trattoria is a charming Italian restaurant located at 2370 Belmont Avenue in New York, United States. Known for its authentic Italian cuisine and warm, inviting atmosphere, Antonio's Trattoria offers a wide variety of traditional dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. From homemade pasta and wood-fired pizzas to delicious seafood and decadent desserts, there is something for everyone to enjoy at this beloved neighborhood eatery. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner for two or a casual meal with friends and family, Antonio's Trattoria is the perfect spot to experience the flavors of Italy in the heart of New York City.

Roberta's is a renowned restaurant located at 261 Moore Street in New York, United States. Known for its innovative and delicious food offerings, Roberta's has become a popular destination for both locals and tourists alike. The restaurant prides itself on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients to create mouthwatering dishes that are sure to please any palate. With a cozy and inviting atmosphere, Roberta's is the perfect spot to enjoy a memorable dining experience with friends and family. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a special occasion celebration, Roberta's is sure to impress with its delectable menu and top-notch service.

Stefano's Pizzeria & Restaurant, located at 258 State Street in Carthage, New York, is a cozy establishment that prides itself on preparing all of their food from scratch to order. Despite being small, they are dedicated to providing the best and most efficient service possible. Their menu items are available for delivery, with the freshest options for dine-in and the quickest for pick-up. Quality is paramount at Stefano's, as they only use the freshest and best ingredients available. They are currently hiring experienced cooks at their Pulaski location, with pay based on skill, experience, attitude, creativity, and availability. Long-term employment opportunities are available, with competitive pay and benefits for qualifying applicants.

Jay's Artisan Pizzeria is a cozy and inviting restaurant located on Delaware Avenue in Kenmore, New York. We specialize in crafting delicious, handcrafted pizzas using only the finest, freshest ingredients. Our menu features a variety of artisanal pizzas, made-to-order salads, and delectable desserts. Whether you're dining in with friends and family or grabbing a quick bite to go, Jay's Artisan Pizzeria offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere for all pizza lovers. Come visit us at 2872 Delaware Avenue and experience the mouthwatering flavors of our authentic, made-from-scratch pizzas.

Avanti Pizza & Wood-Fired Kitchen is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 500 Main Street in Medina, New York. Specializing in delicious wood-fired pizzas, this eatery offers a unique dining experience with a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients and traditional cooking techniques. Guests can enjoy a variety of gourmet pizzas, as well as a selection of other Italian-inspired dishes, all prepared with care and attention to detail. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, along with friendly service, make Avanti Pizza & Wood-Fired Kitchen a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts in the area.

The Iron Kettle Landmark Restaurant, located at 1009 Olean Road in East Aurora, New York, is a renowned food establishment offering high-quality meals made from scratch daily with fresh ingredients. With a rich history dating back to 1947, the restaurant has been a favorite spot for generations of customers to create lasting memories with loved ones. The cozy atmosphere of the restaurant, complete with two fireplaces, provides a welcoming setting for guests to enjoy their meals. The facility also offers easy access from a spacious parking lot, making it convenient for all visitors.

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, located at 1018 South Clinton Avenue in Rochester, New York, has been a staple in the South Wedge & Swillburg neighborhoods since 2007. Owned by Greg Dillingham, this location offers delicious pizza and Italian dishes for dine-in, takeout, or delivery. If you're interested in opening your own Salvatore's location, they are open to discussing opportunities. Gift cards are available for purchase online in various denominations. All Salvatore's locations are locally owned and committed to providing the finest food options for families, teams, or groups in the Rochester area. Visit Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria for a taste of authentic Rochester cuisine.

Located at 1290 Mount Hope Avenue in Rochester, New York, Mavrik's Pizza is more than just a pizza place - it's a family. Our commitment to preserving the traditional art of pizza-making sets us apart from the rest. Our hand-stretched dough is made fresh daily, topped with our secret family recipe sauce, and generously layered with fresh toppings made with love. Whether you dine in or take out, we guarantee a top-notch experience every time. Come join our pizza family at Mavrik's Pizza today!

The Tavern 19 is a renowned food institution located at 1549 Lake Road North, Hamlin, New York, United States. Specializing in wood-fired pizza, The Tavern 19 was inspired by the award-winning Goodfella's restaurant in NYC. The owners installed the first revolving wood-fired brick oven in upstate New York, cooking pizzas at a scorching 900 degrees in the old-world tradition. Using only the finest ingredients such as fresh mozzarella, imported San Marzano tomatoes, and gourmet sauces made from scratch, The Tavern 19 offers a truly artisanal pizza experience. Customers rave about the delicious flavors and quality of the pizzas, with many claiming it to be the best they've ever tasted. Come and enjoy a taste of world-famous pizza at The Tavern 19!

Mangia 2.0 is a food institution located at 71 West Main Street in Allegany, New York, offering the best New York style Pizza in the Southern Tier. Our high-quality food is made from scratch using only the freshest ingredients. You can dine in, pick up your order, or have it delivered right to your doorstep. Delivery is available throughout Allegany, Saint Bonaventure University, and Olean, NY. Don't miss out on our special offer - purchase any size pizza and add wings for only $12.50 per dozen! Choose from our meal deals, such as One 16" Cheese Pizza, One Dozen Wings, and One 2 Liter of Soda for $30.00, or go big with options like Two Large 16" Pizzas, Two Dozen Wings, and Two 2 Liter of Soda for $58.00. Indulge in delicious food at Mangia 2.0 today!

Pasta-eria is a charming Italian restaurant located at 440 South Oyster Bay Road in Hicksville, New York. This cozy eatery offers a wide variety of delicious pasta dishes made with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. From classic spaghetti and meatballs to creamy fettuccine Alfredo, Pasta-eria has something for everyone to enjoy. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner. Come experience the taste of Italy right here in the heart of Long Island at Pasta-eria.

Avellino Ristorante & Pizzeria, located at 9703 64th Avenue in New York, United States, has been a beloved institution since 1977. As a family-owned and operated business spanning three generations, we take pride in serving up authentic Italian specialties and delicious pizza. Our menu features dishes made fresh daily from scratch, using only the finest ingredients. Whether you choose to dine in, take out, or have your meal delivered, Avellino is the perfect choice for a satisfying meal made with love and quality ingredients.

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria is a beloved institution located at 240 West Commercial Street in East Rochester, New York. Founded in 2005 by Carl Horsford, Salvatore's offers delicious meals for delivery, takeaway, or dining in their cozy restaurant. Carl's dedication to his customers and the East Rochester community sets Salvatore's apart from other pizza chains. With a focus on building relationships and providing top-quality food, Salvatore's has become a staple in the area. If you're interested in owning your own Salvatore's location, they are open to discussing opportunities. Gift cards are also available for purchase online. Proudly locally owned, Salvatore's is committed to serving the Rochester area with the finest selection of foods since 1978. Visit Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria for a taste of authentic Italian cuisine and exceptional service.