The 30 Best Island vacation rentals in New York

Welcome to Beach Or Bust Travel, your premier travel agency located on East Main Street in the charming town of East Islip, New York. At Beach Or Bust Travel, we are dedicated to crafting unforgettable travel experiences that cater to your every need and desire. Whether you're dreaming of a sun-soaked beach getaway, an adventurous expedition, or a cultural exploration, our expert team is here to make it happen. Our personalized service and extensive knowledge of destinations around the globe ensure that your vacation is perfectly tailored to your preferences. From booking flights and accommodations to arranging guided tours and unique excursions, we handle all the details so you can focus on enjoying your journey.

Welcome to Great South Bay Charters Inc., your premier travel agency in Bay Shore, New York. Nestled in the heart of Long Island, we specialize in creating unforgettable charter experiences on the stunning Great South Bay. Whether you're looking to explore the serene waters, enjoy a day of fishing, or celebrate a special occasion, our expert team is dedicated to crafting personalized adventures tailored to your desires. At Great South Bay Charters Inc., we pride ourselves on our commitment to exceptional service and attention to detail. Our fleet of well-maintained vessels, coupled with our experienced and friendly crew, ensures a safe and enjoyable journey for all ages. From intimate gatherings to larger group events, we cater to a variety of needs, making sure your time on the water is both memorable and unique.

Welcome to Key West Islip Beach, your serene escape nestled in the heart of Islip, New York. Located at 600 South Bay Avenue, our beautiful park offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and recreational activities for visitors of all ages. Whether you're looking to unwind by the sparkling waters, enjoy a family picnic, or embark on an adventure, Key West Islip Beach has something for everyone. Our park features pristine sandy shores, lush green spaces, and scenic walking trails that invite you to explore and connect with nature. Families can delight in our well-maintained playgrounds, while fitness enthusiasts can take advantage of our jogging paths and open areas for sports and activities. With ample picnic spots and barbecue facilities, it's an ideal destination for gatherings and outdoor celebrations.

Welcome to Cedar Beach Marina, a picturesque natural feature nestled along the scenic Ocean Parkway in Babylon, New York. Located at the heart of Long Island's stunning South Shore, our marina offers a serene escape for boating enthusiasts and nature lovers alike. With its prime location at 11702 Ocean Parkway, Cedar Beach Marina provides easy access to the beautiful waters of the Great South Bay, making it an ideal spot for sailing, fishing, or simply enjoying the tranquil surroundings. Our marina is equipped with modern amenities and services to ensure a comfortable and enjoyable experience for all visitors. Whether you're docking for the day or planning a longer stay, you'll find everything you need right here. Explore the nearby beaches, take a leisurely stroll along the waterfront, or relax and soak in the natural beauty of the area.

Welcome to Second Neck Creek Fishing Dock, a serene haven for fishing enthusiasts and nature lovers alike. Nestled at 66 Riviera Drive in the picturesque community of Mastic, New York, our park offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. At Second Neck Creek Fishing Dock, you'll find a beautifully maintained space perfect for a day of relaxation and outdoor enjoyment. Our dock provides easy access to the abundant waters of Second Neck Creek, making it an ideal spot for both seasoned anglers and beginners eager to cast their lines. The creek is home to a variety of fish species, ensuring a rewarding fishing experience for all.

Welcome to Sailnofo, your premier travel agency located in the heart of Greenport, New York. Nestled at 500 Beach Road, our agency is perfectly positioned to offer you unforgettable travel experiences both near and far. At Sailnofo, we specialize in crafting personalized journeys that cater to your unique tastes and desires, ensuring every trip is memorable and seamless. Whether you're dreaming of a serene beach getaway, an adventurous sailing expedition, or a cultural exploration of new destinations, our team of dedicated travel experts is here to make it happen. We pride ourselves on our extensive knowledge, personalized service, and commitment to creating the perfect itinerary tailored just for you.

Welcome to Sea Dog Cruising, your premier private charter service located in the heart of Greenport, New York. Nestled at 112 Main Street, our travel agency specializes in creating unforgettable cruising experiences across the stunning waters of Block Island, Long Island, Shelter Island, Watch Hill, and the Connecticut Shores. Whether you're seeking a tranquil dock & dine charter, a picturesque sunset cruise, or a unique venue for an intimate corporate function, Sea Dog Cruising offers customized itineraries tailored to your desires. Our private boat service ensures an exclusive and intimate atmosphere, perfect for up to six guests, making your time on the water truly special. From Montauk to Sag Harbor, Northport to Huntington, and Stamford to Westport, our expertly curated journeys promise to deliver unparalleled relaxation and enjoyment. Let us craft a memorable maritime adventure that you'll cherish for a lifetime. Join us at Sea Dog Cruising for an exceptional cruising experience that guarantees satisfaction and delight.

Welcome to Brick Cove Marina, the premier destination for boaters and families on the North Fork of Long Island. Located at 1760 Sage Boulevard, Southold, New York, our marina offers a perfect blend of relaxation and adventure, accommodating 138 boats up to 60 feet. With exclusive access to the picturesque Peconic Bay and breathtaking beachfront views of Shelter Island, Brick Cove Marina ensures an unforgettable boating experience. Our slip holders enjoy numerous amenities, including shore power, fresh water, a private grilling area, and a state-of-the-art multisport court for pickleball, basketball, or tennis. While court time is complimentary for slip holders, it is also available for reservation by the general public.

Welcome to Kenney's Beach, your serene escape located on Sound Avenue in the charming town of Southold, New York. Nestled along the picturesque shores of the Long Island Sound, Kenney's Beach offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and relaxation. Whether you're a local resident or a visitor exploring the North Fork, our beach provides a tranquil setting for a day of sunbathing, swimming, or leisurely strolls along the shoreline. At Kenney's Beach, you'll find pristine sands, gentle waves, and breathtaking sunsets that create unforgettable memories. Our convenient location makes it easy to access nearby attractions, including local vineyards, quaint shops, and delicious dining options. With ample parking and well-maintained facilities, Kenney's Beach is an ideal destination for families, couples, and solo adventurers seeking a peaceful retreat.

Welcome to Sag Harbor Village Marina, your premier destination for maritime adventures and relaxation in the heart of the Hamptons. Nestled at 1a Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, New York, our marina offers a picturesque setting with stunning views of the harbor and easy access to the vibrant local community. Whether you're a seasoned sailor or a casual boater, our state-of-the-art facilities and friendly, knowledgeable staff are here to ensure a seamless and enjoyable experience. Our marina provides a range of amenities, including modern docking facilities, fueling services, and 24/7 security, ensuring your vessel is safe and well-cared for. Enjoy convenient access to nearby attractions, charming shops, and delightful dining options that make Sag Harbor a beloved destination for visitors and locals alike.

Welcome to Sag Harbor Excursions, your premier travel agency located at the picturesque 1 Long Wharf in Sag Harbor, New York. Nestled in the heart of this charming seaside village, we specialize in crafting unforgettable travel experiences tailored to your unique desires. Whether you're seeking a serene getaway, an adventurous exploration, or a cultural immersion, our expert team is dedicated to curating the perfect itinerary just for you. At Sag Harbor Excursions, we pride ourselves on our local expertise and personalized service. Our extensive knowledge of the area and beyond allows us to offer a wide range of travel options, from luxurious yacht charters and scenic coastal tours to bespoke vacation packages and exclusive local experiences. We are committed to ensuring that every detail of your journey is seamlessly executed, providing you with peace of mind and the freedom to fully enjoy your adventure.

Welcome to Polar Charters: Your Gateway to Sailing Adventures in Peconic Bay Located at 525 Orchard Street, New Suffolk, New York, Polar Charters is your premier travel agency specializing in unforgettable sailing experiences. As a family-owned business with deep roots in the maritime history of the Peconic Bay, we are thrilled to offer a variety of sailing adventures for the 2024 season.

Welcome to The Roxy Cape Vincent, your premier lodging destination nestled in the charming village of Cape Vincent, New York. Located at 111 West Broadway, our establishment offers a perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and local charm, making it an ideal choice for travelers seeking a memorable stay in the heart of the Thousand Islands region. At The Roxy, we pride ourselves on providing warm hospitality and a relaxing atmosphere, ensuring each guest feels right at home. Our well-appointed rooms are designed with your comfort in mind, featuring modern amenities and cozy furnishings to enhance your stay. Whether you're here for a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a peaceful retreat, The Roxy Cape Vincent is dedicated to making your visit unforgettable.

Welcome to Paumanok Vineyards, a premier destination for wine enthusiasts and tourists alike, nestled in the heart of Long Island's picturesque North Fork. Located at 1074 Main Road, Aquebogue, New York, our family-owned vineyard invites you to explore the rich flavors and unique experiences that our award-winning wines have to offer. At Paumanok Vineyards, we pride ourselves on our commitment to quality and sustainability, producing exceptional wines that capture the essence of our unique terroir. Our diverse selection includes a variety of reds, whites, and rosés, each crafted with passion and precision. Whether you're a seasoned connoisseur or a curious newcomer, our knowledgeable staff are eager to guide you through a tasting journey that highlights our signature blends and limited editions.

Welcome to J & S Reeve Cottages, your premier destination for waterfront vacation rentals on Long Island, NY. Located at 28 White's Lane, Aquebogue, New York 11931, our charming cottages offer a tranquil escape nestled along the serene shores of Reeves Creek and the Peconic Bay. Discover a unique lodging experience with our selection of six beautifully appointed cottages, each designed to provide you with the utmost comfort and relaxation. Whether you're seeking a cozy retreat or a spacious getaway, our cottages cater to all your needs, offering self-catering facilities and stunning waterfront views.

Welcome to Lighthouse Marina, your premier destination for boating and leisure located in the heart of Aquebogue, New York. Nestled along the scenic Meeting House Creek, our marina offers a serene and picturesque setting for both seasoned mariners and casual boating enthusiasts alike. At Lighthouse Marina, we pride ourselves on providing top-notch services and amenities to ensure a memorable experience on the water. Our full-service marina features a range of facilities, including convenient docking, fueling stations, and boat maintenance services. Whether you're looking to set sail for a day of adventure or simply relax by the water, our friendly and knowledgeable staff are here to assist with all your boating needs.

Welcome to East End Getaway, your premier travel agency located at 431 East Main Street, Riverhead, New York 11901. Discover the enchanting Eastern End of Long Island, the perfect beach getaway right in New York City’s backyard. Whether you're planning a family vacation, a romantic escape, or a solo adventure, East End Getaway offers personalized itineraries that cater to all ages and interests. Explore the vibrant communities from Riverhead to Orient to Montauk, where you'll find the iconic Hamptons, North Fork farms and vineyards, local breweries, and breathtaking beaches. Dive into a world of cultural and recreational activities, from tall ship and music festivals to thrilling drag racing events. Don't miss attractions like the Long Island Aquarium, Splish Splash Water Park, and the Parrish Art Museum.

Welcome to Peconic River Campground, your premier destination for outdoor adventure and relaxation in the heart of Calverton, New York. Nestled along the scenic banks of the Peconic River at 312 South River Road, our campground offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and modern amenities, making it an ideal getaway for families, couples, and solo travelers alike. At Peconic River Campground, we pride ourselves on providing a serene and welcoming environment where guests can unwind and reconnect with nature. Whether you're pitching a tent under the stars, parking your RV, or choosing one of our comfortable lodging options, you'll find the perfect spot to relax and enjoy the great outdoors.

Welcome to Tiana Shores Association Inc., your premier destination for relaxation and recreation in Hampton Bays, New York. Nestled at 17 Oldfield Lane, our unique establishment offers a blend of natural beauty and modern convenience, catering to a variety of interests and needs. As a multifaceted business, Tiana Shores Association Inc. serves as a tranquil campground and lodging site, perfect for those seeking a peaceful retreat amidst the stunning landscapes of Long Island. Our well-maintained park provides an ideal setting for outdoor activities, family gatherings, and leisurely strolls, allowing you to immerse yourself in the serene surroundings.

Welcome to East End Laundry Service, your premier destination for comprehensive laundry and linen solutions in Moriches, New York. Conveniently located at 290 Montauk Highway, we specialize in delivering top-notch services tailored to meet the diverse needs of businesses, vacation rentals, and residential clients across Long Island. Our commercial laundry and linen services are designed to elevate your business or office environment, ensuring your clients and staff enjoy a pristine and professional atmosphere. For short-term and vacation rental properties, we offer seamless laundry and linen delivery services that enhance guest satisfaction by providing fresh, clean linens that create a cozy and welcoming ambiance.

Welcome to Ann Finneran, Woodstock Way Realty, LLC, your trusted partner in real estate located in the heart of Bethel, New York. Situated at 2027 New York 17B, our firm specializes in providing personalized and professional real estate services to meet all your buying, selling, and renting needs. With a deep understanding of the local market and a commitment to exceptional customer service, we are dedicated to helping you find the perfect property or achieve the best value for your sale. Whether you're seeking a serene retreat in the picturesque Catskills or looking to sell your home with confidence, Ann Finneran, Woodstock Way Realty, LLC is here to guide you every step of the way. Discover the difference of working with a team that truly cares about your real estate journey. Visit us today and let us make your real estate dreams a reality.

Welcome to Nest Seekers International, your premier destination for real estate excellence located at 505 Park Avenue, Manhattan, New York. As a pioneering force in the global real estate marketplace, we blend cutting-edge technology with a powerful brand to redefine industry standards. Our innovative approach and bold marketing strategies have revolutionized the way people perceive real estate, making us a leader in this dynamic sector. With headquarters in New York and London, Nest Seekers represents some of the world's most coveted properties in the most desirable regions across the globe. Our curated selection of fine homes and estates showcases the pinnacle of luxury living.

Welcome to Nest Seekers International, your premier destination for exceptional real estate services and general contracting expertise in Queens, New York, and beyond. Located at 47-44 Vernon Boulevard, Queens, NY 11101, Nest Seekers is a pioneering force in the global real estate marketplace, known for its innovative approach and cutting-edge technology. As a hybrid tech and brand-enabled firm, Nest Seekers has redefined the industry with daring and unconventional marketing strategies that elevate the real estate experience. Our headquarters in New York and London position us to represent some of the world’s most sought-after properties in the most desirable regions.

Welcome to Nest Seekers International, located at 578 Driggs Avenue in the heart of Brooklyn, New York. As a dynamic general contractor and real estate agency, we are at the forefront of the rapidly evolving global real estate marketplace. Our hybrid tech and brand-enabled model has sparked a new wave of innovation in the industry, revolutionizing traditional real estate marketing with bold and unconventional strategies. Nest Seekers International is headquartered in both New York and London, proudly representing some of the most coveted properties in the world's most desirable locations. We invite you to explore our curated selection of extraordinary homes and estates, each offering a unique blend of luxury and exclusivity.

Welcome to Nest Seekers International - Your Gateway to Luxury Real Estate Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 1107 Bedford Avenue, Nest Seekers International stands as a transformative force in the global real estate market. As a pioneering real estate agency, we are redefining the industry with our hybrid tech and brand-enabled model, inspiring a new era of innovation and unconventional marketing strategies. Our approach has not only elevated but revolutionized the way people perceive real estate.

Welcome to AM Realty & Building Management Located at 8708 18th Avenue, Brooklyn, New York, AM Realty & Building Management is your trusted partner in real estate and property management. As a dedicated real estate agency in Brooklyn, we pride ourselves on truly caring for the needs of both property owners and tenants. Our mission is to provide the best real estate solutions, ensuring your peace of mind with our 24/7/365 availability.

Welcome to Prestige Home Buyers, your trusted partner in selling your home quickly and hassle-free! Located at 198 Charter Oaks Avenue, Brentwood, New York, we specialize in providing homeowners across Long Island with a seamless and stress-free way to sell their properties for cash. At Prestige Home Buyers, we believe in empowering you to sell on your terms. Our process is designed to eliminate the traditional headaches associated with selling a home. We buy houses in any condition, and you don’t even need to clean or make repairs. Say goodbye to commissions, fees, and lengthy waiting periods. With us, you can get a no-obligation cash offer and close the deal in as little as five days!

Welcome to "New Home with Nick," your premier destination for exceptional real estate services in Bellport, New York. Located at 112 South Country Road, Bellport, NY 11713, our business is dedicated to helping you find your dream home or sell your property for top dollar. Imagine living in an expansive North Fork waterfront dream home with breathtaking views and luxurious amenities. With four bedrooms and four bathrooms, this stunning property offers an impressive entry foyer, a large chef's kitchen, and a spacious living room and den, each featuring side-by-side fireplaces. The massive basement and stand-up attic provide an additional 1,500 sqft of potential living space, perfect for families or those seeking extra room to grow.

Welcome to Shirley Motel, your comfortable and convenient lodging choice located at 681 Montauk Highway, Shirley, New York. Nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, our motel offers a warm and inviting atmosphere for travelers seeking a restful stay on Long Island. Whether you're here for business or leisure, Shirley Motel provides an ideal base with easy access to nearby attractions, beaches, and the scenic beauty of the area. Our well-appointed rooms are designed to offer comfort and relaxation, featuring modern amenities to ensure a pleasant stay. Enjoy complimentary Wi-Fi, flat-screen televisions, and cozy bedding to make you feel right at home. We pride ourselves on our friendly service and commitment to guest satisfaction, ensuring that your visit is both enjoyable and memorable.

Welcome to Kapell Real Estate Inc., your trusted partner in navigating the vibrant real estate market of Greenport, New York. Conveniently located at 400 Front Street, our agency is dedicated to providing exceptional service to our clients, whether you're buying, selling, or renting property in the beautiful North Fork region. With a deep understanding of the local market and a commitment to personalized service, our team of experienced professionals is here to guide you through every step of the real estate process. We pride ourselves on our integrity, local expertise, and a client-first approach that ensures your real estate journey is smooth and rewarding.