TOP 30 Best Food gifts in Bay Shore, New York

North Shore Country Store is a charming cafe and home goods store located in Bernhards Bay, New York. Situated at 676 New York 49, this quaint establishment offers a cozy atmosphere where customers can enjoy delicious food and browse through a variety of unique home goods. From freshly brewed coffee and tasty pastries to handcrafted decor items and kitchen essentials, North Shore Country Store has something for everyone. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or searching for the perfect gift, this delightful store is sure to have just what you need. Visit North Shore Country Store today and experience the warmth and hospitality of this hidden gem in upstate New York.

Butera's in Bay Shore is the newest addition to the Butera Restaurant Group, offering a casual and comfortable dining experience with a sleek industrial edge. Located at 8 Third Avenue in Bay Shore, New York, the restaurant features cool green and white panels, brick, subway tile, marble, and original artwork. The spacious dining room and large bar create an open and airy atmosphere, with garage doors that bring the outside in. Since 1991, the Butera kitchen has been serving up traditional rustic Italian cuisine with a modern twist. The menu features interesting specials showcasing authentic ingredients and local products. The Butera family is excited to begin a new chapter in Bay Shore and looks forward to serving and delighting the community for years to come.

Silver Bay General Store is a convenient one-stop shop located at 8417 Lake Shore Drive in Silver Bay, New York. This institution offers a wide range of products and services, including groceries, snacks, beverages, gas, and various household items. Whether you're a local resident or a traveler passing through, Silver Bay General Store is the perfect place to refuel, grab a quick bite to eat, or pick up any essentials you may need. With friendly staff and a convenient location, this store is a must-visit destination for all your shopping needs.

Bay Shore Bean is a charming cafe and food store located at 47 East Main Street in Bay Shore, New York. Serving up a delicious array of coffee, pastries, and light bites, this cozy establishment is the perfect spot to grab a quick bite or enjoy a leisurely meal. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, Bay Shore Bean is a popular destination for locals and visitors alike looking for a tasty treat and a friendly atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a freshly brewed cup of coffee or a sweet pastry, you're sure to find something to satisfy your cravings at Bay Shore Bean.

Welcome to Market at Bay Shore, your premier shopping destination located at 1320 Illinois Avenue, Bay Shore, New York. Nestled in the heart of the vibrant Bay Shore community, our shopping mall offers an unparalleled retail experience for visitors of all ages. Discover a diverse selection of stores featuring the latest in fashion, technology, home goods, and more. Whether you're looking to update your wardrobe, find unique gifts, or enjoy a delightful meal, Market at Bay Shore has something for everyone. With ample parking and a welcoming atmosphere, our mall is the perfect place to spend a leisurely day shopping, dining, and exploring. Visit us today and experience the best of Bay Shore's retail offerings.

Welcome to Hyde Bay, a serene and captivating park nestled in the heart of Cooperstown, New York. As a premier tourist attraction, Hyde Bay offers visitors an enchanting escape into nature's beauty, blending picturesque landscapes with recreational activities for all ages. Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat or an adventurous day out, Hyde Bay provides an idyllic setting for picnics, hiking, and family gatherings. Explore our well-maintained trails that meander through lush greenery, offering stunning views of the bay and surrounding countryside. For those who love the water, enjoy kayaking or paddleboarding on the tranquil waters, or simply relax on the shores and soak in the natural beauty.

Welcome to Bay Shore Commons Located at 521 Montauk Highway in the vibrant heart of Bay Shore, New York, Bay Shore Commons is your premier shopping destination. As a part of the esteemed Milbrook Properties portfolio, our mall benefits from nearly a century of expertise in the real estate industry. Milbrook Properties has been a trusted name along the East Coast, known for their commitment to quality and excellence in both commercial and residential properties.

Welcome to South Shore Market, your go-to destination for fresh and locally sourced products in Bay Shore, New York. Conveniently located at 99 Maple Avenue, our market is dedicated to providing the community with a wide selection of high-quality groceries, artisanal goods, and specialty items. At South Shore Market, we pride ourselves on supporting local farmers and producers, ensuring that our customers have access to the freshest produce, meats, and dairy products available. Our shelves are stocked with a diverse range of organic and sustainable options, catering to various dietary needs and preferences.

Welcome to Shore Pkwy/Brown St Transit Station, your gateway to convenient and efficient travel in the heart of Brooklyn, New York. Located in the vibrant neighborhood of Sheepshead Bay, Shore Pkwy/Brown St serves as a crucial hub for commuters and travelers alike. Our station is designed to provide seamless connectivity and easy access to various public transportation options, ensuring you reach your destination with ease. Whether you're heading to work, exploring the city, or visiting friends and family, Shore Pkwy/Brown St offers a reliable transit experience with well-maintained facilities and a commitment to passenger safety. Our location in Brooklyn 11235 is easily accessible and strategically situated to connect you to key areas within the city.

Goldy's Gems is a cozy bar located at 5 Third Avenue in Bay Shore, New York. This hidden gem offers a unique atmosphere where you can relax and enjoy a wide selection of drinks in a laid-back setting. Whether you're looking to unwind after a long day or catch up with friends, Goldy's Gems is the perfect spot to kick back and have a great time. With friendly staff, delicious cocktails, and a welcoming vibe, this bar is sure to become your new favorite hangout spot. Come visit us at Goldy's Gems for a memorable night out in Bay Shore!

Welcome to Beverage Barn, your premier destination for an exceptional selection of fine wines, spirits, and craft beers in Bay Shore, New York. Conveniently located at 4951 Garfield Street, our locally-owned liquor store offers a curated collection of beverages to suit every palate and occasion. Whether you're searching for a rare vintage, a bold new craft beer, or a classic favorite, our knowledgeable and friendly staff are here to assist you in finding the perfect drink. At Beverage Barn, we pride ourselves on providing personalized service and expert recommendations. Visit us today and explore our extensive inventory in a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere. Cheers to great taste and unforgettable experiences at Beverage Barn!

Welcome to Genesis Specialty Bakery, your go-to destination for delightful and unique baked goods in Bay Shore, New York. Conveniently located at 12 Drayton Avenue, our bakery is dedicated to crafting an array of exquisite treats that are sure to satisfy your cravings and elevate any occasion. At Genesis Specialty Bakery, we pride ourselves on using only the finest ingredients to create our diverse selection of baked goods. From artisanal breads and pastries to custom cakes and confections, our products are lovingly prepared to bring joy to your taste buds. Whether you're stopping by for a morning pastry, selecting a cake for a special celebration, or seeking a unique gift, our friendly staff is here to assist you in finding the perfect treat.

Jade Garden Chinese Restaurant is a popular dining destination located at 297 Bay Shore Road in Deer Park, New York. This establishment offers a wide range of delicious Chinese dishes in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. From traditional favorites like General Tso's chicken and lo mein to more unique offerings such as Peking duck and Szechuan beef, Jade Garden has something to satisfy every craving. Whether you're dining in or taking out, the friendly staff at Jade Garden is dedicated to providing top-notch service and ensuring a memorable dining experience for every guest. Come visit Jade Garden Chinese Restaurant and taste the flavors of authentic Chinese cuisine right here in the heart of New York.

The Barn Pet Feed & Supplies is a premier food and supply store for all your pet's needs. Located at 315 Bay Shore Road in Deer Park, New York, this institution offers a wide range of high-quality products for your furry friends. From premium pet food to toys, accessories, and grooming supplies, The Barn has everything you need to keep your pets happy and healthy. With a knowledgeable staff and a friendly atmosphere, this store is the perfect place to shop for all your pet care essentials. Visit The Barn Pet Feed & Supplies today and treat your pets to the best in quality products.

Welcome to Shell, your one-stop destination for convenience and quality located at 515 Montauk Highway, Bay Shore, New York 11706. As a multifaceted local business, we pride ourselves on offering a wide range of services to meet your everyday needs. Whether you're fueling up your vehicle, grabbing a quick bite, or managing your finances, Shell is here to make your life easier. Our gas station provides high-quality fuel to keep your journey smooth and efficient. Inside our convenience store, you'll find a variety of snacks, beverages, and essential items to keep you going throughout the day. Looking to withdraw cash or handle banking needs? Our on-site ATM ensures that financial transactions are convenient and hassle-free.

Welcome to Gardiner Manor Mall, your premier shopping destination located at 834 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore, New York. Nestled in the heart of Long Island, Gardiner Manor Mall offers a diverse and vibrant shopping experience for visitors of all ages. With a wide array of retail stores, dining options, and entertainment venues, our mall is the perfect place to shop, dine, and unwind. Explore our extensive selection of popular brands and local boutiques, ensuring you'll find everything from the latest fashion trends to essential everyday items. Whether you're searching for the perfect outfit, unique gifts, or home essentials, Gardiner Manor Mall has it all.

Welcome to Wines On Main, your premier destination for fine wines and spirits located at 567 East Main Street in the heart of Bay Shore, New York. As a locally-owned and operated business, we pride ourselves on offering an exceptional selection of wines, craft beers, and premium liquors to satisfy every palate and occasion. Whether you're a connoisseur seeking rare vintages or a casual enthusiast looking for the perfect bottle to complement your meal, our knowledgeable staff is here to guide you through our curated collection. At Wines On Main, we are dedicated to providing personalized service and sharing our passion for quality beverages with the Bay Shore community and beyond. Visit us today and discover a world of flavors waiting for you at Wines On Main. Cheers!

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant is a popular dining destination located at 1684 Shore Parkway in New York, United States. This establishment offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy delicious Italian cuisine. From classic pasta dishes to mouthwatering seafood entrees, Olive Garden has something for everyone. Whether you're looking to dine in or take your meal to go, this restaurant provides exceptional service and quality food. Come experience the taste of Italy at Olive Garden Italian Restaurant.

King Kullen is a one-stop destination for all your grocery and shopping needs, conveniently located at 834 Sunrise Highway in Bay Shore, New York. This institution offers a wide range of services including an ATM, bakery, finance services, florist, and a variety of food options. With a diverse selection of products, King Kullen is your go-to supermarket and store for fresh produce, pantry staples, and household essentials. Experience top-notch customer service and quality offerings at King Kullen.

Welcome to FYE, your ultimate destination for entertainment and more, conveniently located at 1701 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore, New York 11706. As a unique blend of an electronics store, food haven, and retail paradise, FYE offers an unparalleled shopping experience for all ages. Explore our extensive selection of the latest electronics, from cutting-edge gadgets to essential accessories, ensuring you stay connected and entertained. Whether you're a tech enthusiast or just looking to upgrade your devices, our knowledgeable staff is here to assist you in finding the perfect products to suit your needs.

Welcome to Subway® located at 1490 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, New York! Our local restaurant is your go-to destination for delicious food, whether you're craving a quick meal or planning a catered event. At Subway®, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that includes our famous Footlongs, 6” sandwiches, wraps, and salads, all crafted with fresh veggies and a variety of protein choices. Our commitment to quality means freshly baked bread and delightful cookies are always on the menu. Explore our catering options with Subway® Catering, perfect for gatherings of any size. Choose from your favorite subs, drinks, chips, and cookies, all conveniently bundled for easy ordering online. We also offer a selection of fresh veggies that allow you to customize your meal as a sandwich, wrap, or salad. For those with dietary preferences, select stores offer a six-inch gluten-free bread option, baked off-site to ensure safety from cross-contamination.

Welcome to Superior Bagel & Deli, your go-to destination for delicious, freshly baked goods and scrumptious deli delights in Deer Park, New York. Conveniently located at 297B Bay Shore Road, our cozy bakery and food store offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes every visit a delightful experience. At Superior Bagel & Deli, we pride ourselves on using high-quality ingredients to craft an array of mouthwatering bagels, sandwiches, and deli specialties. Whether you're grabbing a quick breakfast on the go, enjoying a leisurely lunch, or picking up a tasty treat, our friendly staff is here to serve you with a smile.

Welcome to BevMo Wine & Liquor, your premier destination for an exceptional selection of wines, spirits, and more, located conveniently at 1566 Brentwood Road, Bay Shore, New York. As a trusted local food and liquor store, we pride ourselves on offering an extensive variety of products to satisfy every palate and occasion. Whether you're a wine enthusiast looking for that perfect bottle, a cocktail connoisseur seeking rare spirits, or simply stocking up for your next gathering, BevMo Wine & Liquor is here to meet your needs. Our knowledgeable staff is always ready to assist with personalized recommendations and expert advice. Visit us today and discover why BevMo Wine & Liquor is Bay Shore’s go-to store for quality and variety.

Welcome to Peter 99 Cent, your go-to destination for unbeatable deals and a wide variety of products, conveniently located at 1574 Brentwood Road, Bay Shore, New York. As a beloved local store, we take pride in offering our community an extensive selection of everyday essentials, all priced at just 99 cents. From household items and kitchenware to personal care products and seasonal decorations, Peter 99 Cent has everything you need to make your shopping experience both enjoyable and affordable. Our friendly and helpful staff are always on hand to assist you in finding exactly what you're looking for. Visit us today and discover why Peter 99 Cent is a favorite among Bay Shore residents for quality products at incredible prices!

Welcome to Top Smoke, your one-stop destination for convenience and quality in Bay Shore, New York. Located at 1647 5th Avenue, our versatile store combines the essentials of an ATM, convenience store, finance services, food, and liquor store all under one roof. Whether you're in need of quick cash, everyday groceries, financial assistance, or premium beverages, Top Smoke has you covered. Our friendly staff is dedicated to providing exceptional service to meet all your daily needs. Stop by today and experience the convenience and variety that make Top Smoke a local favorite.

Welcome to Exxon Bay Shore, your trusted local gas station conveniently located at 1501 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, New York 11706. We are dedicated to providing our community with high-quality fuel and exceptional customer service. At Exxon Bay Shore, you'll find a variety of fuel options to meet your vehicle's needs, along with a well-stocked convenience store offering snacks, beverages, and essential travel items. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff are here to assist you and ensure a smooth and efficient fueling experience. Whether you're a local resident or just passing through, Exxon Bay Shore is your reliable stop for all your fueling needs. Visit us today and experience the quality and convenience that Exxon is known for.

Welcome to your local Subway® located at 1701 Sunrise Highway Fc2/Food Court, Bay Shore, New York 11706! As a premier destination for food, meal takeaways, and dining in, we pride ourselves on bringing bold flavors and classic favorites to our valued guests every day. Indulge in our famous Footlongs, 6” sandwiches, wraps, and salads, all crafted with fresh-cut veggies, protein choices, and our signature fresh-baked bread. Don't forget to treat yourself to our delicious cookies! At Subway®, we believe in offering more than just a meal. Customize your order with our variety of fresh ingredients, and explore our catering options for your next event. With Subway® Catering, you can easily order your favorite subs, drinks, chips, and cookies online—let us handle the rest!

Welcome to Baskin-Robbins, your go-to destination for delightful treats and unforgettable flavors, located conveniently at 19 Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore, New York. As a beloved local bakery and food store, we specialize in bringing joy to the community with our extensive range of delicious ice creams, cakes, and desserts. Known for our iconic 31 flavors, we offer a diverse selection that caters to all taste preferences, ensuring there's something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a sweet craving, our friendly staff is here to make your experience memorable. Visit us today and discover why Baskin-Robbins has been a trusted name in delightful desserts for generations.

Welcome to Conoco Gas Station, your reliable local fuel stop conveniently located at 195 Pine Aire Drive, Bay Shore, New York 11706. We are dedicated to providing you with high-quality fuel and exceptional customer service to ensure your journey is smooth and hassle-free. Whether you're a local resident or just passing through, Conoco is your go-to destination for all your fueling needs. Our well-maintained facilities and friendly staff are here to assist you, making your visit quick and efficient. Stop by today and experience the convenience and quality that Conoco Gas Station has to offer. Safe travels!

Chipotle Mexican Grill at 1675 Sunrise Highway in Bay Shore, New York is a popular food destination known for its delicious Mexican cuisine. The restaurant offers a variety of options including chicken, white rice, black beans, fresh tomato salsa, and queso blanco, as well as steak, supergreen lettuce blend, fajita veggies, cheese, guacamole, and tomatillo red-chili salsa. Customers can also enjoy dishes like white rice, pinto beans, cheese, romaine lettuce, roasted chili-corn salsa, fresh tomato salsa, sour cream, and guacamole. With its fresh ingredients and flavorful menu items, Chipotle Mexican Grill is a must-visit for those craving authentic Mexican flavors.