Cakes for celebration in Centereach, New York

Welcome to The Cookie Shop, your go-to destination for delectable treats in Centereach, New York! Nestled at 115 Mark Tree Road, our cozy bakery is a haven for cookie enthusiasts and anyone with a sweet tooth. We specialize in crafting a wide array of freshly baked cookies, each made with love and the finest ingredients. At The Cookie Shop, we pride ourselves on offering a delightful selection of classic and innovative cookie flavors that are sure to satisfy every craving. From timeless chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin to unique creations like salted caramel pecan and white chocolate cranberry, our menu has something for everyone. We also feature a variety of seasonal specialties and custom cookie options for special occasions.

Welcome to Benkert's Bakery, where tradition meets excellence at 2216 Middle Country Road, Centereach, New York. For four generations, the Lorch and Janke families have dedicated themselves to delivering top-notch service and superior products. Our commitment to using only the finest ingredients ensures that freshness and quality are always at the forefront of what we offer. At Benkert's Bakery, we pride ourselves on building lasting relationships with our customers, who we consider family. Our reputation as the finest bakery on Long Island—and beyond—is a testament to our unwavering dedication to excellence.

Welcome to Cold Stone Creamery, your ultimate destination for delectable desserts and delightful experiences in Centereach, New York! Conveniently located at 2350 Middle Country Road, our store is a haven for ice cream enthusiasts and dessert lovers alike. At Cold Stone Creamery, we pride ourselves on crafting the finest ice creams, cakes, and other sweet treats, all made fresh in-store daily. Our unique concept allows you to customize your dessert just the way you like it. Choose from a wide array of premium ice cream flavors, mix-ins, and toppings to create your perfect treat. Whether you're in the mood for a classic sundae, a signature creation, or a custom ice cream cake for a special occasion, we have something to satisfy every craving.