The 30 Best Authentic italian in New York City, New York

Welcome to Sbarro, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in Bay Shore, New York! Conveniently located at 1701 Sunrise Highway, our restaurant offers a delightful dining experience for anyone craving classic Italian flavors. Whether you're looking to dine in, grab a quick meal to go, or have delicious food delivered right to your doorstep, Sbarro has you covered. Indulge in our famous New York-style pizzas, made with hand-stretched dough, rich sauces, and topped with the freshest ingredients. Our menu also features a variety of pastas, salads, and Italian specialties that are sure to satisfy any palate. Perfect for a family meal, a quick lunch, or catering for your next event, Sbarro is committed to providing high-quality food and exceptional service.

Welcome to Amore Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Bay Shore, New York. Conveniently located at 2110 Union Boulevard, we are proud to serve our community with a wide array of mouth-watering pizzas, pastas, and classic Italian dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. At Amore Pizza, we believe in using only the freshest ingredients to create meals that are bursting with flavor. Our talented chefs are committed to crafting each dish with love and attention to detail, ensuring an unforgettable dining experience for every guest. Whether you're in the mood for a traditional Margherita pizza, a hearty plate of spaghetti, or a fresh salad, our diverse menu has something for everyone.

Welcome to Jersey Mike's Subs, your go-to destination for delicious, freshly made subs in Bay Shore, New York. Conveniently located on Montauk Highway, we pride ourselves on offering a wide variety of mouthwatering sandwiches, crafted with the freshest ingredients and served with a smile. Whether you're grabbing a quick meal to go, enjoying a relaxing dine-in experience, or picking up a catering order for your next event, Jersey Mike's Subs is here to satisfy your cravings. Our menu features a selection of both classic and unique sub sandwiches, all made to order with premium meats and cheeses, freshly baked bread, and garden-fresh vegetables. We also offer a range of sides, drinks, and desserts to complement your meal. At Jersey Mike's, we believe in quality and authenticity, which is why we prepare everything with care and attention to detail.

Welcome to The Pizzeria of Babylon, your go-to destination for authentic and delicious pizza in the heart of Babylon, New York. Conveniently located at 217 East Main Street, our cozy and inviting restaurant offers a warm atmosphere perfect for family gatherings, casual dinners, or a quick bite with friends. At The Pizzeria of Babylon, we are passionate about crafting the perfect pizza using the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes. Our menu features a wide variety of options, from classic Margherita and pepperoni pizzas to gourmet creations and customizable pies that cater to every palate. In addition to our mouthwatering pizzas, we offer a selection of salads, appetizers, and desserts to complete your dining experience.

Welcome to Parini Pizza & Pasta, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of West Islip, New York. Conveniently located at 504 Union Boulevard, our restaurant is dedicated to serving delicious, handcrafted dishes that bring the taste of Italy to your table. At Parini Pizza & Pasta, we pride ourselves on using only the freshest ingredients to create a wide array of mouth-watering pizzas, pastas, and more. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty lasagna, or a refreshing Caprese salad, our menu offers something to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to Pulcinella on the Green, a delightful culinary destination nestled in the heart of Wading River, New York. Located at 141 Fairway Drive, our charming restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy an unforgettable dining experience. At Pulcinella on the Green, we take pride in serving an exquisite selection of authentic Italian dishes, crafted with the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes. Our menu features a variety of mouthwatering options, from classic pasta dishes and hand-tossed pizzas to delectable seafood and succulent meats. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner, our diverse offerings are sure to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to Brezza Pizza Kitchen, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic pizza and Italian cuisine in Wading River, New York. Conveniently located at 5768 New York 25A, our cozy restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for family dinners, casual outings, and special occasions. At Brezza Pizza Kitchen, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients and time-honored recipes to craft mouthwatering pizzas and a diverse menu of Italian favorites. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty pasta dish, or a crisp, refreshing salad, our menu has something to satisfy every palate. Join us for a delightful dining experience, or take advantage of our convenient takeout and delivery options. Come taste the difference at Brezza Pizza Kitchen, where every bite is a breeze of flavor!

Welcome to Bernie's Family Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic pizza in the heart of Moriches, New York. Conveniently located at 225 Montauk Highway, our family-owned and operated restaurant is dedicated to serving up mouth-watering pizzas made with the freshest ingredients and a whole lot of love. At Bernie's Family Pizzeria, we believe that quality and tradition go hand in hand. Our menu features a wide variety of classic and specialty pizzas, all crafted with our signature homemade dough and sauce. Whether you're a fan of the timeless Margherita or looking to try something new like our popular BBQ Chicken Pizza, there's something for everyone to enjoy.

Welcome to Carmelina's Pizzeria & Ristorante, where authentic Italian flavors meet the heart of Center Moriches. Nestled at 794 Montauk Highway, our family-owned restaurant invites you to indulge in a culinary journey through Italy with a menu that bursts with traditional and innovative dishes. Our pizzas are crafted with love, featuring the finest ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and aromatic basil, all drizzled with extra virgin olive oil on a perfectly thin crust. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita or a unique twist like our Chicken, Bacon, Ranch pizza, we promise each bite will transport you to the streets of Naples.

Welcome to Carlo’s Pizza Of Manorville, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Manorville, New York. Conveniently located at 287 Wading River Road, our family-owned restaurant prides itself on serving mouth-watering pizzas made with the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita, a hearty Meat Lover's, or a customized creation of your own, our skilled chefs craft each pizza to perfection. Beyond our signature pizzas, Carlo’s Pizza Of Manorville offers a diverse menu that includes savory pasta dishes, crisp salads, and delectable appetizers, ensuring there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Our cozy and welcoming atmosphere is perfect for family dinners, casual lunches, or a quick bite with friends. We are committed to providing exceptional service and a memorable dining experience for all our guests.

Welcome to Southold Mediterranean Restaurant, your go-to destination for an authentic and delightful Mediterranean dining experience in the heart of Southold, New York. Conveniently located at 53345 Main Road, our restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can enjoy the rich and diverse flavors of the Mediterranean. Our menu features a wide array of dishes that highlight the vibrant and fresh ingredients synonymous with Mediterranean cuisine. From savory Greek gyros and traditional Italian pasta to flavorful Middle Eastern kebabs and refreshing Mediterranean salads, each dish is crafted with care to transport your taste buds to the sun-kissed shores of the Mediterranean.

Welcome to Touch of Venice, a charming culinary haven nestled in the heart of Cutchogue, New York. Located at 28350 Main Road, our restaurant offers an exquisite blend of authentic Italian flavors and local charm, making it a must-visit destination for both locals and travelers alike. At Touch of Venice, we pride ourselves on delivering an exceptional dining experience with a menu that celebrates the rich traditions of Italian cuisine. Our skilled chefs use the freshest ingredients to craft dishes that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. From classic pasta creations to innovative seafood dishes, every meal is a celebration of taste and tradition.

Welcome to DOPO La Spiaggia, a charming culinary destination nestled at 6 Bay Street, Sag Harbor, New York. Situated just across the street from the picturesque waterfront, our restaurant invites you to indulge in the finest Tuscan cuisine that the Hamptons has to offer. Our menu boasts a delightful array of steaks, pastas, seafood, and more, each dish crafted with passion and authenticity. Whether you're joining us for a cozy dinner, a leisurely weekend lunch, or simply to enjoy cocktails, you'll find a welcoming atmosphere both indoors and outdoors. Experience the taste of Tuscany right here in Sag Harbor, and let us be your go-to spot for memorable dining moments.

Welcome to Michelangelo Pizzeria, your go-to destination for authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Mattituck, New York. Located at 10095 Main Road, our charming pizzeria invites you to savor a delightful array of traditional and contemporary Italian dishes. At Michelangelo Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft our mouthwatering pizzas, pastas, and classic Italian entrees. Whether you're in the mood for a crispy, wood-fired pizza topped with premium mozzarella and fresh basil or a hearty plate of homemade lasagna, our menu offers something to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to Primavera Pizza, your go-to destination for mouthwatering Italian cuisine in Mattituck, New York. Nestled at 13500 Main Road, we offer a delightful array of food options that are sure to satisfy your cravings. As a beloved local pizzeria, we've been serving the community with passion and dedication, becoming a favorite spot for residents and visitors alike. At Primavera Pizza, we take pride in crafting delicious meals using only the freshest ingredients. Our menu features a variety of delectable options, from our classic cheese pizzas with thin crust to specialty creations like ricotta and baby spinach pizza, and BBQ chicken with mozzarella. Indulge in our savory sandwiches, fresh salads, and hearty calzones. Don't miss our signature garlic knots, a perfect accompaniment to any meal.

Welcome to Grana Trattoria Antica & Enoteca Nestled in the heart of Jamesport, New York, at 1556 Main Road, Grana Trattoria Antica & Enoteca is a culinary gem where the soul of Italy meets the bounty of fresh, local ingredients. At Grana, we live by the three rules of Italian cooking: ingredients, ingredients, ingredients. Our passion for authentic Italian cuisine is evident in every dish we serve, crafted with the finest quality ingredients to bring you an unforgettable dining experience.

Welcome to Il Giardino Restaurant by John Gambino, a charming culinary haven nestled in the heart of Aquebogue, New York. Located at 739 Main Road, our establishment offers a delightful blend of authentic flavors and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Whether you're looking for a relaxing evening at the bar, a satisfying meal with family and friends, or a convenient takeaway option, Il Giardino is your perfect destination. Our menu features a diverse selection of exquisite dishes, crafted with the freshest ingredients and inspired by traditional and contemporary culinary techniques. From sumptuous appetizers to mouthwatering entrees and decadent desserts, every dish is a testament to our passion for quality and flavor.

Welcome to Lenny's Pizza & Bistro, affectionately known as Lenny's of Jamesport, where the taste of Brooklyn meets the charm of Long Island. Conveniently located at 1451 Main Road in Jamesport, New York, our establishment has been a beloved culinary destination for over 30 years. Owner Lenny Lubrano brings his authentic Brooklyn New York City Recipe Pizza to the residents and visitors of Jamesport, Riverhead, Mattituck, and the wider Suffolk and Nassau County areas. At Lenny's, we pride ourselves on offering a delightful dining experience with our Original Brooklyn Recipe Pizza, expertly crafted in our brick-oven and wood-fired ovens. Whether you're dining in or taking out, our traditional pizzeria promises the finest Italian flavors. Our cozy dining room, open Wednesday through Sunday from 4 p.m. to closing, invites you to enjoy a full menu of Italian specialties, daily specials, and a full-service bar.

Welcome to Sergio's Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in Riverhead, New York! Conveniently located at 739 Old Country Road, we are proud to serve the community with a mouthwatering menu that features a variety of classic and contemporary dishes. Whether you're craving a piping hot pizza, a hearty pasta dish, or a fresh salad, Sergio's Pizza has something for everyone. As a family-owned and operated establishment, we are dedicated to using only the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes to deliver the rich flavors of Italy right to your table. Our warm and inviting atmosphere makes Sergio's Pizza the perfect spot for a casual lunch, a cozy dinner, or a special celebration with loved ones.

Welcome to Caruso's Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Riverhead, New York. Conveniently located at 1104 Old Country Road, we pride ourselves on serving a wide variety of mouth-watering pizzas, pastas, and classic Italian dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. At Caruso's Pizzeria, we use only the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes to bring the rich flavors of Italy straight to your table. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty lasagna, or a fresh Caprese salad, our menu has something for everyone. Our cozy and welcoming atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for a family dinner, a casual lunch with friends, or a quick bite on the go.

Welcome to Rocco's Pizza, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Riverhead, New York, at 1285 Old Country Road. At Rocco's, we pride ourselves on serving an exquisite array of Italian delicacies that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Our menu is a celebration of fresh ingredients and authentic flavors, crafted with love and passion. Indulge in our signature pizzas featuring fresh plum tomato, garlic, olive oil, and a blend of mozzarella cheeses, all on a perfectly thin crust. Explore our gourmet selections like chicken cutlet with ricotta and marinara sauce, or savor the delightful combination of chicken, broccoli, and tomatoes with pesto.

Welcome to Carlo's Pizza Oven, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic pizza and more in Riverhead, New York. Located at 435 Osborn Avenue, our restaurant is a beloved part of the community, offering a diverse menu that caters to all taste buds. At Carlo's Pizza Oven, we specialize in thin pan-style pizzas, freshly cooked with our signature marinara sauce and topped with mouthwatering mozzarella. Our pizzas feature a variety of fresh toppings, from juicy tomatoes, broccoli, and spinach to savory sausage, pepperoni, and meatballs. For a unique twist, try our cheesy bread—a delightful cross between garlic bread and pizza, perfect for any gathering.

Welcome to Barrila's Pastaria Restaurant & Bar, located at 300 East Main Street, Riverhead, New York, where culinary artistry meets authentic Italian tradition. Immerse yourself in the gourmet world of Chef Marco Barrila, who invites you to experience an open kitchen concept, allowing guests to witness the creation of artisanal dishes crafted by hand and cooked fresh just for you. At Barrila's, we celebrate the rich and diverse culinary traditions of Italy, showcasing the best of authentic Italian cuisine. Our expansive antipasti bar, light-filled dining room with soaring ceilings, pasta laboratory, pizzaiola station, Italian dessert section, and take-away market create a unique dining journey. Each dish is a testament to our commitment to quality, flavor, and the vibrant culinary culture of Italy.

Welcome to Marco's Sicilian Pizza & Pasta, where we serve up Riverhead's most beloved pizzas and pastas right in the heart of the city. Located at 300 East Main Street, Riverhead, New York 11901, our restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. We pride ourselves on offering some of the finest pizzas in the area, and once you try our delicious creations, you'll understand why Marco's is the go-to spot for pizza lovers in Riverhead. Our menu features a variety of mouthwatering options, including the popular meatball parmigiana hero, a perfect complement to any of our pizzas. At Marco's Sicilian Pizza & Pasta, we're dedicated to bringing you the best of Riverhead's culinary scene, with a focus on fresh ingredients and authentic flavors.

Welcome to Il Pellicano Southampton, your premier dining destination nestled in the heart of Southampton, New York. Located at 136 Main Street, our restaurant invites you to embark on a culinary journey filled with bold flavors and the highest quality ingredients. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Il Pellicano Southampton offers an exceptional dining experience that caters to all taste preferences. Our menu is crafted to delight your senses, featuring a diverse selection of dishes that highlight the richness of authentic flavors. We take pride in using only the freshest ingredients to ensure each meal is not only delicious but also memorable.

Welcome to Insatiable Eats Creative Kitchen Catering & Event Specialists, where culinary artistry meets authentic Italian tradition. Nestled at 42 Montauk Highway in Southampton, New York, our establishment is a haven for gourmet lovers seeking handcrafted, freshly cooked artisanal food. Step into our insatiable world, designed by the renowned Chef Marco Barrila, where an open kitchen invites you to witness the magic of Italian cuisine. Our expansive antipasti bar, sunlit dining room with towering ceilings, and the unique pasta laboratory where fresh pastas are crafted on-site, promise an unforgettable dining experience. Delight in Sicilian-style pizza alla pala, an Italian dessert section, and a take-away market, all curated to tantalize your taste buds.

Welcome to Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour - The Hamptons Institution Since 1968! Nestled in the heart of Hampton Bays at 42 East Montauk Highway, we are a beloved culinary landmark known for delighting locals and visitors alike with our delicious, authentic pizzas and Italian specialties. With over five decades of experience, Uncle Joe’s has become synonymous with quality, tradition, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Whether you're looking to enjoy a cozy meal in our charming restaurant, grab a quick takeaway, or have a delicious dinner delivered straight to your door, Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour is here to serve you with a smile. Our diverse menu features a variety of classic and gourmet pizzas, hearty pastas, fresh salads, and mouth-watering appetizers, all crafted with the freshest ingredients and a dash of love.

Welcome to Scotto's Pork Store, your go-to destination for fine Italian foods in the heart of Hampton Bays. Located at 25 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, New York, we have been proudly serving the East End of Long Island since 1997. Our family-owned business specializes in lunch, dinner, pick-up, delivery, and catering services, ensuring you enjoy authentic Italian flavors wherever you are. At Scotto's, we take pride in our homemade fresh mozzarella, signature sauces, sausage, focaccias, pasta, and more, all crafted daily from cherished family recipes passed down through generations. Our commitment to quality and tradition shines through in every bite, making us a beloved staple in the community.

Welcome to East Garden, your premier destination for delicious and authentic cuisine in Manorville, New York. Conveniently located at 460 County Road 111, our restaurant is dedicated to providing a memorable dining experience, whether you choose to join us in-house or enjoy our convenient meal delivery service. At East Garden, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that caters to a variety of tastes and preferences. Our skilled chefs use only the freshest ingredients to craft mouth-watering dishes that are sure to satisfy your cravings. From traditional favorites to innovative new creations, our menu offers something for everyone.

Welcome to Pennachio's Restaurant & Pizzeria, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in Manorville, New York. Located at 460 County Road 111, our family-owned restaurant has been serving the community since 2017 with a commitment to quality and flavor. At Pennachio's, we believe that the secret to great food lies in the freshest ingredients, prepared with love and pride. Indulge in our wide range of Italian specialties, from voluminous entrees and fresh salads to our mouth-watering pizza pies, all crafted to delight your taste buds. We are proud to offer meal delivery and takeaway services, ensuring that you can enjoy our delicious offerings wherever you are in Manorville, Eastport, and Moriches areas.