Amore Pizza

"If I could give 10 stars I would. The whole staff here is beyond amazing. They make my mother in law feel so special every time we come in, and the food is always hot and fresh. Full of flavor but not grease."

"I have lived in Bay Shore my entire life, and I just found this hidden Gem! Orders for take out never disappoints! Best food and service! When I ask for thin crust pizza , it is thin , crispy and oh my gosh, Best pizza ever!"

"Ordered an XL Garbage pie and delivered is something totally different from past orders. The meat Garbage pie was more vegetables than meat. $29.95 for thin crust, burnt onions and under cooked green peppers and barely any meat and not able to be cut with a sharp knife. Not to mention the unprofessional way the phone was answered, yelling could be heard. Amore's quality is going down hill. When the delivery person called the store they were argumentative, stating it was what I ordered. I won't be ordering again. Wish I could post a picture of the pie today verses the same pie ordered 12/22, totally different. Wish I could give zero stars! The owner is just as rude cursing us out over the phone because of this review. I guess he can't handle the truth about the business."

"I ordered the 14" garbage pie expecting it to be a small version of the vegetable garbage pie because I am allergic to dairy. It was missing the spinach, broccoli, and eggplant. It had pepperoni and sausage. This was a phone order so I ate it, but I am disappointed. I will not be ordering from this restaurant again. They are not reliable. Also, the spaghetti sauce was very little and needed to use more than what was given. These meals were not worth the cost."