Yetty's Pizza

"I have loved growing up with their freshly made Italian-American foods. The upside down pizza is classic. Hoping these guys will remain in good standing for years to come!"

"Have been a customer for nearly 50 years and my most recent visit did not disappoint. I was born around here and my family moved away when I was pretty young, but I’ve never been back to Herkimer without at least grabbing a pizza at Yetty’s. Added some riggies and wings to the take-out order this time and everything was FANTASTIC! Great pepper flavor in the riggies and don’t sleep on the garlic bread. It was my wife’s first time here. She’s not easy to impress with pizza and pasta, but thought the food was great and really appreciated your extra-friendly service when picking up the order. Thanks for continuing to deliver the goods after so many years. See y’all again in a few years!"

"Yettys chicken tenders are so good. If you're not into upside-down pizza, visit for the other menu items. I had tendies, pizza, & Cinnamon sugar fried dough bites. All were so yummy. The dining room is lovely. OH! They sell shirts & hoodies with a clever slogan!"

"We have pretty good Italian Restaurants in our town but nothing like this. Hands down the best sauce we've had a long time. The service was incredible. Clean environment. Plenty of seating. Plenty of street parking. Very reasonable prices. Plenty of food options to pick from no matter what mood you're in."

"2nd time visiting better than the first time. I got the shrimp riggies and my wife got the cheese pizza. The pizza she said was fine but lacked cheese as seen in the pictures The riggies were a bit tasteless mild shouldn't mean no heat.(normally I go hot but the last time it was not edible the amount of peppers they added.) The sauce was broken and had chunks of curdled heavy cream in it. The bread hasn't changed its just heated no flavor and a little wirl added on tip with parm cheese."