Fat Cats 200 King Street, Herkimer, NY 13350

"Order at the counter, staff was friendly, sat in a nice clean room filled with other folks quietly eating, Nickey was very friendly and brought my order in minutes and recommended the potato salad which was great. Fish portion was more than I needed, also had the clams, both were breaded and cooked perfectly. I will visit again without a doubt."

"It's easy to see why this place was voted # 1 for Best Fish Fry in NY State. The quality never wavers, the quantity of food is amazing. It's worth the trip to get a hot tasty dinner and to top it off with a soft serve ice-cream cone."

"Figured I’d give Fat Cats a try haven’t had anything from here in a long time. Usually you expect the food from a place like this to hit just right - didn’t for me. Don’t get me wrong wonderful people, nice at the counter and everything. However my Fish and Chips - The fish itself was super bland, fish had no seasoning and was dry. Fries were Fries, over salted but ok. The Shrimp - Shrimp wasn’t even peeled. Also super bland. I’m biting into it and chewing and tasting bits of the shrimp skin. So awesome. Appreciate the effort but some seasoning, and de-skinning the shrimp would’ve been awesome"

"French fries, fish, fried scallops are my favorites! Sometimes you need to queue on Fridays!"

"Friendly staff and prompt service. Fish dinner was very good and a generous portion for the price. Definitely a place loved by locals. Don't let the worn down exterior fool you."