The Pizzeria of Bay Shore

"The pizzeria is like our second home. The staff, food, atmosphere… everything is outstanding. We come here more than once a week. We may be addicted. Uncle Benny and Trifecta 4 Life!!! In the winter, the crowd at the bar is welcoming and the bartenders are always so personable. In the summer, they have live music and an awesome outdoor area to enjoy. They also run specials each week (buy one get one pizza Mondays and buy one get one pasta Wednesdays). They are also great supporters of local law enforcement! We are proud to have this amazing family and business in our neighborhood! Thank you for everything Pizzeria of Bay Shore! Shout out to all the staff: Cassie, Max, Hilary and all of the amazing crew. We love you guys!"

"Truly one of if not the best pizza spots on the island. The food is consistently amazing . It’s always busy but they manage to remember everyone with a family vibe, Kyle and the staff remembers us by name every time. Went to pick up our family order, they had all the games on and the charismatic bar tender Brandon had me sitting down enjoying a drink in no time while I waited for our food. Great prices great people Can’t say enough, love supporting our pizza family. Customers for life."

"Great location. Very clean spacious modern restaurant. Authentic pizza with modern twist. Good value. Service could be more customer friendly."

"New pizzeria and clean. Great decor and good location. Love the outdoor sitting. Service was quick but they lacked smile and not too friendly. Food is also good so no major complaints here. Come visit them."

"We really enjoyed the fun menu at this pizzeria! They had different crust options, and pizzas with a sweet and salty vibe. I never thought of hot honey as a pizza topping, but it was a nice surprise. They also have more traditional pizza options, and a build-your-own pizza option as well. Not in to pizza? No worries! This restaurant offers plenty of other options! Plus, the vibe is really cool, with an indoor/outdoor dining area that’s perfect for warmer days in this beach community."