Jimmy's New York Pizzeria Broken Arrow 3312 South Elm Place, Broken Arrow, OK 74011

"They have a great pie...the wife had a veggie and I pepperoni....I thought by the way people were eating this pizza by folding it over....it was going to be tuff like a lot of the NY pizzas are but I was pleased to see that this wasn't the case the foundation (crust) was thin but tender and crunchy. The toppings were good and the wife also could not find falt with her pie.....however, pizza is everywhere...that the great thing about pizza...it's all different but good...but, we both thought for what you ended up getting was good just ridiculously over priced."

"Had a little gathering at my sisters and she asked to pick up some food. Thought I’d give this place a go. First time trying their pizza. Great service over the phone, great staff when I arrived. Extremely clean inside as well. I ordered this to go and our pizza was still nice and warm. Food consistency was great! Only comment I’d make is the calzone was a bit doughy and the cheese wasn’t really melted. Not the end of the world as it was still delicious. Definitely will be back in the future."

"First Time stopping into Jimmy's for a pie. Good amount of pizza options or you can select your own toppings for your pie. Tried the pepperoni roll and Brooklyn Prosciutto pizza. Crust was perfect on the pizza thin and cooked to perfection. Garlic sauce paired with mozzarella, asiago, grape tomatoes, and basil blended well together to provide a decent flavor balance. Definitely will be back to try out some more pizza. Staff is friendly."

"Best New York style pizza I've had in Oklahoma! Toppings were fresh, crust was perfect, and not greasy at all. The staff was super friendly, and the service was quick. I've found my new pizza spot."