NY Pizza & Bagel Cafe

"We met up with some friends for breakfast that have been here before and it wasn't bad at all. It was more of a brunch so it wasn't crazy busy. The staff were all friendly and a fellow NY'er by chance. We placed our order and sat down. The prices to me are on the borderline of being a little high, a bagel with just butter is 4 bucks and I just can't wrap my head around that. I ordered the bagel BLT and the wife had an omelette and a bagel with cream cheese. The food came out relatively quickly and everything tasted good. The inside was clean and had a nice NY atmosphere. We'll have to stop back and try the pizza products and see how they are as well. Overall good experience."

"I order quite often for my lunch break. The service is great, the place is insanely clean, and ordering online on their website is so easy. The bagel sandwiches and garlic knots are always DELICIOUS. They look and taste home made and never need any sauce (aka never dry). However, I’m quite disappointed with my tenders and fries meal today. The tenders were not good at all and my 4th one was barely a tender. I wish I didn’t get them but the fries were at least fine. On another note, when I ordered garlic knots online it clearly says that it includes marinara sauce. When I picked up my online order I had to come back and ask for it. The gentleman at the counter said that it’s not included (gave it to me anyways). Not so much a complaint, but maybe get on the same page so that I know to order it separately next time. I hope to try the pizza soon but overall love this place."

"Had a great 12inch NY cheese after my dentist appointment The shop is nice and clean. Pizza was basic, great and authentic. Just what I wanted. Thank You!"

"This was the absolute worst pizza we've ever had. The whole experience was terrible. When I called to order I was told 30 min. I arrived to pick up 30 minutes after placing the order and was told "we're still working on it." Ok no biggie, right? I understand being a couple minutes behind. Except it turned out they hadn't even started making mine yet. I sat there for an additional 30 min until mine was ready. I had ordered one cheese pizza, one pepperoni pizza. After all that time the cheese pizza was still undercooked and had almost no cheese on it. The pepperoni pizza was clearly two different pies. Half had obviously just been baked and the other half looked like it had been sitting out for days. It was inedible. Everyone in my family tried a slice of pizza and we threw the rest away. Almost $50 for two pizzas and they were the worst we've ever had. So much sauce that the crust was completely soggy, almost no cheese, super greasy, and half of our pepperoni pizza was old?! Who serves something like that?? They should be ashamed. You'd think after waiting an hour you'd get two fully cooked, hot/fresh pizzas. Will never return and will definitely tell all of our friends about our experience."

"A classic NY Italian style restaurant. The food is great, prices are reasonable and the staff helpful. They’ll totally customize a pizza for you, which I like. They also have brunch on the weekends, we’ll try that next."