Wisconsin Mutual Insurance

"I've had this insurance for over 12 years. I needed the roadside assistance at one point and was told I would have to pay for my tow and they would reimburse me. This was very unhelpful but I still stuck with this insurance company. We recently had a big power outage due to the bad weather which left my home uninhabitable. No heat, or electricity in 5 below cold weather. l called the 24 hour emergency number around 1030pm on a Saturday. I didn't get a return call until the next morning around 9.The rep told me Wisconsin mutual does not cover loss of living due to power outages. At this point I really see no reason to keep this insurance and will be searching for new auto and home insurance."

"They are not a good homeowners insurance company. They are cheap for that reason. It took us 6+ months to get our claim approved, even with the damaged proof and pictures, and then another 4 months to get the check! Then with our second claim, in the 7 years we’ve had this insurance, we had water damage, and it took them 3 months to send us a check! Then they want to drop us because of 2 claims. They punish you for using the service you pay for! Thank heavens as we were looking into other insurance companies after our second claim! Would never go with the company, and I steer all my family and friends away from them."

"Horrible experience, had no problem accepting my premium payments for years, but was a huge hassle when it came time to pay out for my claim. Dropped them for auto insurance also after pulling this stunt. Would not recommend this company."

"Absolute worst insurance company EVER!!!!!!!! Had home insurance through them for 8 years, never made a claim and now they drop me for paint peeling around my windows among other things. They seemed quite happy to drop me and I was quite happy to find way better home insurance, not only cheaper but WAY better coverage. I truly do feel bad for people who have to deal with this garbage insurance company. Thankfully, I'll never have to hand another dime over to these crooks! Good luck with these clowns!"

"We paid this company for home insurance and car insurance (as many as four cars at a time) for many many years. Last week they decided that we had too many claims (chalk that up to teenage boys and bad luck). So they're dropping our auto coverage. Well, we’re dropping them altogether. Pretty much a no brainer decision, especially after they announced last month that they're no longer covering hail and wind damage to roofs like they used to."