Prost! MSN

"Great service and food. No reservations but wait is not bad. Family style tables to share. Unlike some places, the benches have an open area behind them for servers and others to be able to seat without everyone having to get up. Noise level is high, but everyone having a grand time."

"Excellent food and prices are very affordable for the size of the meals. Also, there are a lot of beer options and N/A beers (which is not very common!). Big TVs in the walls to enjoy the games. This is a perfect place for a big group; the main area offers big long tables. The restaurant is always clean and service is very friendly. Parking is on the street."

"Cool venue with an authentic German Beer Hall feel. Nice waitress and menu. The Sauerbraten and spaetzle were great. Only wish the red cabbage was tangier as with the German potato salad, but a great place worth a visit."

"Atmospheric German Restaurant! Spätzle too! Pros: Terrific building - it's an old church after all. Marvelous service! Good German food! Cons: No cons come to mind. (The Spätzle I received seemed "old." The waiter checked. It was. It was because the chef hadn't arrived yet. However, the chef arrived while I was there and made a fresh batch for me. So, I guess this is a pro in the end.)"

"Great use of the old church. Food wad very good, would love to see a bit of a menu expansion to complement what is already of. If I'm ever back in Madison I will certainly eat here again."