Tarantino's Pizzeria 2577 South 68th Street, Milwaukee, WI 53219

"So, I have to give this place a 5 star review on principle alone! I live in the neighborhood and have ate here before but didn't remember due to it being years ago before the Vid lol. I was reluctant to go here because on yelp they have bad reviews, on Google not so much, but still underrated in my opinion! I then remembered there are a bunch of Karen's and entitled people in the world! This place is great! Just ate here on March 9th 2024. Food is restaurant quality at bar price food. Think I plaid 13.75 for a large 3 topping pizza. It was good, sauce excellent, cheese excellent, toppings excellent. I am posting this honest review out of greed! I don't want to loose this place in the neighborhood and will be going once a week, I will also be telling everyone I know. I had the garlic bread also which was great and restaurant quality as well. As a past restaurant owner and a foodie my whole life, 100 percent honest opinion: price matched to quality is a perfect 5 stars (on pizza and garlic bread as this is all I ordered) and I do not know a single person here or not am I affiliated in anyway."

"I have been picking up pizzas here for years. I love their pizza. The place is a bit different , ads to the charm. One time I did get one with a very burnt crust. I took it back in, and he made me a new one. Another I took one in with a slightly burned crust he got a little mad at me and gave me my money back. They were slammed with orders that night. I went back in and got my pizza. The pizza was great as always. It was my bad to complain. I don't eat a lot of pizza for health reasons. Next time I do it will be from Tarantino's I saw another similar post saying give them another chance. I sent a like to that one. P.S. If you happen tool like cold pizza for breakfast this is your spot."

"One and Done: 1st time ever ordering from here. The pizza was raw and undercooked, cheese was literally not melted. Breaded Mushrooms and Mozzarella Sticks were undercooked. Sausage tasted like snausage's. For those of you who don't know what that is: Those are dog treats. We won't be back."

"Every time I’ve ordered tarantino’s it has been amazing but this time was disgustingly disappointing. I spent $50 on a pizza, breaded cauliflower, and 2 cannoli. The pizza was burnt around the entire crust edge but somehow cold, soggy, and borderline raw throughout the rest. It looked and tasted like the canadian bacon was added after it was “cooked”. I ate a couple bites of a small piece and put it back in the box. My boyfriend ate one piece and left the others he grabbed untouched on his plate. The breaded cauliflower was cold and not fried thoroughly so it was nearly raw cauliflower in a fried breading. The cannoli was the only thing that was edible. I talked this place up so much telling my boyfriend how good the food is… but this was a horrible way for him to experience it. Completely ruined my opinion of the restaurant and I doubt I’ll order from them again. Waste of $50."