Park Avenue Pizza Company

"Not good at all! Was there for 20min waiting on a takeout order they said would be done, felt like 16 year olds where running it. They didn't give us the salad, or the appetizer we ordered. Payed 35$ to not get half the food for 2 people so we had to go get more food. In addition, the food we did get smelled and tasted rancid. Ether the milk or cheese went bad, my boyfriend was throwing up 5 min after eating it. We will never be coming back here again. Just go to olive garden, you will get better service and better food sadly."

"Had a longer wait then told (40 mins rather than 15) but the hostess was apologetic. Pizza was excellent! We loved the taco pizza! Also tried the garlic bread, haystack onion rings and a sausage pizza. Everything was good but especially loved the taco pizza! Our waitress was prompt, efficient and friendly. They were pretty busy too. Definitely will come again. Thanks Park Ave Pizza!"

"Very fun and awesome local spot to enjoy a meal out with the family or with a group of friends! Met my girlfriends there for lunch and below is our awesome pizza creation! Love their spaghetti and meatballs too!!"

"Every time I am in Pewaukee, Park Avenue Pizza is a must stop. The crust is original and I cannot find anything like it anywhere! Combined with their tangy sauce and generous cheese, it's always something I look forward to when travelling to Wisconsin. It's a family owned business and the people at Park Avenue make you feel at home. The restaurant itself used to be a movie theater, so it has a unique vibe. Wish they open one in San Diego, CA... then all harmony would exist in my life."

"Came here with just over an hour left before closing on our last night at a hotel/waterpark in touristy Pewaukee. Anywhere my family & I go for a vacation or quick getaway, my wife knows at some point we're gonna be having pizza and obviously in the land of cheese it's definitely happening. With a time crunch at hand and with 2 of the higher or highest rated pizza joints in town closing at 9pm, this was the closer drive for us but I'm sure glad I chose this place. I knew I was gonna love it from the 1st glance outside. Once inside and seeing all the classic cinema posters and memorabilia, I fell in love with the vibe. At still reasonable prices, Park Avenue has a good all around menu and drink menu, clean/sanitized dining room and our server Abby/Abbey did exceptional. The pizza here is dee-lish, I think the Fourteen seasons may have made the pizza a bit salty for my wife but I still very much enjoyed it and my boys enjoyed their sausage pizza. We live more than a 60-mile haul south in Lake County IL and we loved this 2-night quick getaway in Pewaukee. I'm guessing the lake makes it a boaters' paradise during the warm months. Pewaukee seems to be full of surprises as far as the places and restaurants we visited. If ever in the area again, I could definitely go for some PAPC pizza!"