Vintage Indy Sports 2803 East 56th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

"Cons: Often what my biggest pet peeve with card stores in not pricing a lot of items. This opens you up to price discrimination which is not my favorite. Not saying that happens but when you can just look up a price it just comes across as lazy. If you are looking at what market is, what’s the advantage of someone coming to buy from you, when they can get it for the same price online? Additionally, it’s disorganized which made it difficult to sift through cards. Dimly lit wasn’t the most comfortable place to be. You can guess what might be in the boxes that you can see based on the front cards but that’s not even accurate. It’s not straight forward like: “this is the dollar bin” or here are the football cards either. It’s all mixed in together Pros: memorabilia and probably the customer service. Some cool selection of unique Indy items. I can also tell that regulars are treated well here. For the hassle of this, there are many more cheaper and more organized options around the city. It’s worth the drive out of broad ripple."

"I live in Canada and ordered a Peyton Manning Super Bowl XLI bobblehead. There were a lot of issues getting it shipped but they went out of their way to make sure I got it. Great customer service and the product was in near mint condition."

"Great prices and selection! While they specialize in vintage cards and memorabilia, they also offer a large variety of modern as well. Pokémon and other cards and games are available, too. Scott it great to deal with. Highly recommend!"

"Top notch, friendly service. Scott is one of the best in the business. Honest and trustworthy. Always a great selection of memorabilia from all areas!"

"Small shop with lots of great finds. We bought quite a few NFL cards at very reasonable prices."