Barton's Pizzeria 3925 45th Street, Highland, IN 46322

"Foods great ...whoever the manager is there lied about giving us a pizza after they made mistake on our pizza.. this has happened now 3 times altogether.... and for that I'm done with them sadly... I wasn't even the one who said I wanted a pizza they offered it each time... and each time I asked for it she said no all we can do give you $2 or $5 off your pizza.... Sucks I ordered there 2 or 3 times a month..."

"Ummm. Why are people saying this is the best pizza. The pizza is basically, what would happen, if you took a napkin and soaked it in grease. Too thin, greasy and all u taste is bread."

"Barton's was precisely what the doctor ordered today. Family-size Sausage Pizza was delicious, and was ready quicker than we could've made dinner! Can't wait to order again! The tomato bread sounds like it will be great too!"

"Grew up with Barton’s and they still manage to put out a great pizza! The best quality ingredients, best dough! Customer service is always great! Prices are very reasonable. Highly recommend!"

"First time trying Barton’s. Service on the phone was great. Ordered the double Neapolitan with the crumble sausage. Plus an order of tomato bread. Definitely a steep above most chain pizza places. The pizza was on the salty side for me. Parts of the crust were doughier than I liked. Maybe I should order it well done next time? The tomato bread was good, but not excellent. Again, not cooked long enough for me. All in all it was good, not excellent. But the price was affordable and service was great."