Americas Best Value Inn & Suites St. Marys

"This has got to be the dirtiest place I have ever stayed. It is nasty. Food and drink on the counter, on the remote control, missing shelves in the filthy refrigerator.. the couch is all stained and smells like dog pee. Not to mention it is extremely run down and has little to no upkeep or repairs made. The food covered stove doesn't even work."

"The staff was wonderful and I appreciate they had a hot breakfast. The rooms were clean and there's a Dairy Queen across the street so that gave it a great land mark too! We really enjoyed our stay and felt comfortable here"

"Under $100 for the room. Needs upgraded but it served the purpose. I got a good night's sleep and hot shower. Only complaint was waking up to phone ringing at midnight for no apparent reason. We just didn't answer it. Desk staff was very nice. Breakfast was just cereal, muffins, and bagels."

"Good price, clean rooms, very good breakfast of biscuits and gravy. We stayed during a race weekend at Eldora and they had very good pizza available after midnight as they knew some guests would arrive late. Very thoughtful staff! Will stay again."

"Aside from being quite outdated, my suite was clean and cozy and had everything I needed! Very affordable for the King suite. Staff was super nice. Pet friendly!"