Bagel Bros Cafe

"Wanted to like this place based off the reviews. Although it was busy, the smell inside was atrocious. Unfortunately, the bagel wrappers and bag smelled the same which overtook the taste of the bagel. The smell was so strong it permeated my car the whole 20 minute ride home."

"First time trying and unfortunately I’m not sure if I’ll be back. They open at 630am and I got there around 7am. So you can understand why I would be disappointed when i got home and a majority of the bagels were hard. They had to have been from the previous day. No way could these have been freshly made. Not to mention that both the onion and garlic was burnt. Sadly, not the best first experience."

"First and likely last time we will order from here. The bagels are good but we waited 30 minutes for a bagel sandwich. As we waited, multiple Door Dash orders were fulfilled and they continually brought out sandwiches for those orders. The entire inside was stuffed with people and to the point they told everyone they were stopping the grill to let the kitchen catch up. I would think they would turn off online ordering and help their customers inside first but this place doesn't seem to be the case. We saw a lot of unhappy and frustrated people leave. They should rethink how they are operating."

"Ordered this via door dash so I didn’t get a chance to correct the order myself, but we few complaints… everything bagel was ordered with lettuce and a note to please add tomato. Came with neither. It was also burnt, so all the seeds were black and bitter. Spinach “omelette” was literally just eggs with 7 near-raw spinach leaves folded in. It was decent and we ate the food, but I don’t think I’d order it again."

"Bagel bros is as authentic as it gets. And if you’re from the Tri-State area it’ll remind you of home. Mike the owner is a class act and truly represents the American dream. Stop in and treat yourself to the steak, egg & cheese with some home fries, you won’t regret it!"