Brooklyn Joe's Pizza 1133 Bal Harbor Boulevard, Punta Gorda, FL 33950

"We thought we’d branch out and try a new pizza place. We heard some good things about Brooklyn Joes in the PGI Bal Harbor Plaza so we thought we’d give them a try. Our waiter was very friendly and on the way in we saw some folks with a white pizza that looked pretty good. We ordered our standard pepperoni and sausage with two Yunglings. We’d give the pizza a 4 out of 5. It had a nice crispy thin crust with decent toppings and flavor. The crust had a cracker consistency rather than a chewy bread dough feel. Ok, but not like the DoughBar. Reasonably priced. We’d still return. Thayer look like they have some interesting Italian dishes on the menu."

"This was some of the best pizza I have had anywhere in Florida. The Grandma's pizza in particular was outstanding, but the NY style pizza was great as well. I wasn't as high on the garlic knots but they had been sitting a fair amount of time before I had them. Friendly service as.well. I will definitely be back to get more pizza here."

"I have now eaten here three times and I must say that finally there is a place I have found in town that knows how to cook pizza properly. If you like your pizza cooked like it's supposed to be where the crust is actually cooked on the bottom juicy on the inside perfect amount of toppings a good tasting sauce and quality product and this is the place to go. I'm originally from Long Island and I have very regularly eaten pizza in Brooklyn and this is the closest thing you're going to get in Florida that I have seen so far. The price is on par if not better than most places around and they're giving you the quality you deserve for the price. It has a really nice cute atmosphere on the inside and the service is always fast. We recently ordered five pizzas for my son's birthday we didn't order them well done we didn't order any extra instructions we just left them make the pizzas the way that they make them and everything was perfect My entire family is from Long Island and we've eaten everywhere in the city and in Brooklyn and Long Island everywhere around and it's the closest place to home. I am a huge chicken parmesan fan and I can't wait to go back and give that a try."

"Brooklyn Joe’s Pizza, Great Experience!I recently had lunch at Brooklyn Joe's pizza and had an incredible slice of pizza. The flavors were fantastic, and the crust was perfectly crispy. The staff was friendly, and the service was excellent. Highly recommended! Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐"