The Local’s Pizzeria Myrtle Street, Edisto Island, SC 29438

"Not worth the money. Thin super hard crust that you can’t really cut through. The crust breaks rather than tears like pizza should. We went here because the other option was closed. This one was very expensive. $70 for two large pizzas. I left a tip but then later noticed there was 10% surcharge added. The topping were good. However the crust was hard as rocks. It tasted exactly like the flat bread at Panera. My guess is the dough is either par baked first and then put in fridge for the next day. Or it’s cooked so slowly that it is intentionally very hard crust. Everyone likes their pizza differently but this was not good. Reading the other reviews and the comments. Yes I do have the right place. Just outside the Wyndham and there is only a couple places to choose from. The other one was closed. This one had the name on the sign lol. So if you like that kind of thing…. Thin crispy crust. Expensive. Takes 30-40 minutes to cook. Then this place is for you."

"Things I would get again: the meat pizza and garlic knots. Things I would not get again: seabrook pizza & hot boneless wings Things I wish I knew: the Greek pizza is giant and can feed about 6 if using it as a side. Very good. Lots of toppings. Their online ordering said they weren't available for online orders, btw, but they were if I called. This was on a Sunday evening. Took about an hour to get our order. Pickup was easy, but a few miscellaneous charges that added up, making our pizza dinner for 7 $171. 3.5% for using a card (required for the phone order), 10% service fee, and 10% tax. While more yummy than not, it was very pricey at $24 per person for take out pizza."

"We tried Locals while staying in Edisto. Despite seeing some mixed reviews, I thought this place was good. We ordered our pizza online around 5 and it was done around 5:30/5:40, which is reasonable considering the small number of eateries in the area. We ordered the supreme and the Italian. The pizzas have similar toppings, but still tasted different from each other—the supreme pizza had a distinct sweetness that made it tasty. I prefer savory so I still liked the Italian better. You can taste the quality of the cheese and the freshness of the toppings. My only complaint is that the dough felt tough, as if it could have been tossed less. This is a good option if you want an easy dinner, but like everything on the island, you have to order early or be prepared to wait."

"Yummy yummy pizza and super easy to order pickup, they texted me when it was ready. Nice experience! We got 3 Large pizzas and loved them all- I couldn’t pick a favorite between them because they’re all so good. The sausages on the supreme were HUGE!"