Heenan's Irish Pub

"My brother and I stopped at Heenan's for a beer a few years ago. It was busy, we made our way to the bar. The bartenders (both young ladies) seemed to ignore us for a good 10 to 15 minutes while taking orders from other patrons who had clearly come up to the bar after us. One of the bartenders finally took our drink order (and my money before getting our drinks, which I thought was odd). We noticed that she immediately started taking other patrons orders before bringing our drinks. After a few minutes, we got her attention and asked if she forgot our order. She stated that she hadn't taken our order or our money. I asked to speak to the owner. He came over, he was extremely rude. He basically called us liars. After going back and forth for a few minutes, he went to the register, pulled out a 5 dollar bill, balled it up and threw it at us (we had given the bartender a $20). We couldn't believe it. There were even people sitting at the bar that had witnessed us giving money to the bartender and told him so. He didn't care. We haven't been back since. **Update** 11/19/23. Bar owner says that I have the wrong bar. That, of course, is not true. I'm from Westfield NY, 20 minutes from Fredonia. I'm pretty sure I know which bar we were in. Unbelievable. Instead of apologizing and learning from this situation, the owner continues to show his true colors. I wasn't going to name names, Shaun. Smh."

"Great first experience! Met Hillary and the owner. They'll have you coming back for your happy hour every day or week."

"Great place for a good down to earth environment. It's not too roudy, and definitely is a well cared for establishment! No kitchen but there's sometimes food. Pool table and darts also available!"

"Went to the bar to celebrate a birthday. At first the bar was nice and clean, we had 2 tabs open for a few people. Went to close the tabs and both fell under 20 dollars, we were never told that there is a minimum closing tab... which they cant do illegal in New York. Unfortunately this bar wont be seeing us back!!!"