St. Stephens Cafe 2 West Main Street, Brocton, NY 14716

"This review is based on the fish fry, hot pepper crunch roll, and baked goods. The fish fry is excellent, five stars. I would say it's the second best fish fry I've had. (Although a little overpriced for the size of the fish) I ordered the fish extra crispy and it had a nice thick crunchy batter, the fish was cooked perfectly, not slimy at all. There was no skin on the fish, which is a huge plus. Tartar sauce was delicious. The sides were..meh. Coleslaw had a faint flavor of horseradish, the texture was a bit limp and soggy. The fries are not fresh cut, they're frozen, and had some type of seasoning on them. The hot pepper crunch roll appeared to be a prepackaged frozen appetizer that had a decent flavor but the contents in the center were not heated thoroughly. The baked goods were a brownie, white chocolate blueberry turnover, a pumpkin donut, and a cinnamon roll. None of them were good. (Although the icing on the cinnamon roll was good..) The turnover was more like a scone, mealy texture, dry... The cinnamon roll was also dry or stale, not much flavor aside from the icing, the dough was very bland. The pumpkin donut was moist and fresh although the flavor was bland and similar to unsweetened canned pumpkin. The brownie was okay but also rather dry. Will definitely be back for the fish fry and highly recommend it."

"Good food, good service, nice people, nice atmosphere, and some of the best coffee I've had in a long time! But that's not all! Not only is the food good, and the coffee amazing, this cafe also encourages a "pay it forward" type system with any money that's given for tips. Making it not only a delicious food and coffee spot, but also a safe atmosphere for the youths of our community. If you're going to stop anywhere in Brocton for food, or coffee, stop here. They even have a drive thru!"

"Best fish fry I’ve ever had! They offer an awesome menu. So worth finding this sweet spot!"

"Excellent service, great coffee, and delicious food! I had the St. Stephen's Mocha, Broccoli & Cheddar soup with a Grilled Cheese on homemade bread. The atmosphere was relaxing and friendly. Everything was great all around!"