Sweets By Sarah Bakery 591 Main Street, Sterling, NY 13156
About the Business
Sweets By Sarah Bakery is a charming bakery located at 591 Main Street in Sterling, New York. Our dedicated bakers work tirelessly each day to bring you the freshest and most delicious baked goods possible. Start your morning off right with a warm cinnamon roll and a cup of coffee from our bakery.
Owned by Sarah, who recently received the prestigious award for "The Best and Sweetest New Business in Cayuga County in 2022" from the Cayuga County Office of Tourism. Sarah's passion for baking started at a young age and led her to graduate from culinary school in 2020. Following in the footsteps of her family's bakery and restaurant, Sarah is committed to providing only scratch-made baked goods to her customers.
At Sweets By Sarah Bakery, we offer a variety of treats including cookies, cheesecakes, muffins, cinnamon rolls, pies, cake pops, and custom cakes for weddings and special occasions. Visit us at our location in Sterling, New York, and let us satisfy your sweet tooth with our delicious creations.
Photos
Location & Phone number
591 Main St, Sterling, NY 13156, United States
Hours open
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
Closed
Wednesday:
Closed
Thursday:
07:00 - 13:00
Friday:
07:00 - 16:00
Saturday:
07:00 - 16:00
Sunday:
07:00 - 15:00
Reviews
"Let's start with the positives. It is a nice little shop with nice people. Everything presents well. I purchased a chocolate chip cookie, a sandwich cookie, a peach pie bar, a brownie and a cinnamon roll. Total cost $20.59. I have had a worse chocolate chip cookie I just can't remember when. It had no flavor and wasn't baked enough. The sandwich cookie was the same, bland and not baked long enough. The filling tasted like sweetened shortening. The peach pie bar was also disappointing, again very bland. The bottom crust was good and the sliced peach added some much needed flavor. The brownie was a better option. Very fudgy and tasty! The cinnamon roll, although good, did not live up to the rave reviews I'm seeing here. It would have been better without the icing. The icing again was flavorless and there was far too much of it. In all honesty you can get better cookies and frosting from the Wal-Mart bakery. The great reviews I'm seeing here certainly didn't reflect what I tried today."
"The cinnamon buns were gone when we got there, but got to watch Sarah make up a batch for the next day! They looked amazing and weigh about a pound apiece! Everything looked so good and we finally decided on a Lemon Blueberry scone and a cookie! Both were excellent. Great service, good prices and wonderful people and baked goods. If you are near by or even if you want to make a day trip I think you will find it worth it!"
"What! This place has some amazing options. We look everywhere for chocolate orange baked goods and can never find any. The cinnamon rool is dense, which is usually a bad thing. These have a nice little glazed crunch to them with the perfect amount of icing. The cinnamon to rool ratio is almost perfect! Will definitely be going out of my way to return."
"Friendly family run bakery. 1lb cinnamon bun did not disappoint, delicious! Coffee was also delicious and hit the spot, along with lemon cookies and fruit pie bars. Another sparkling delight in this gem of a town Sterling NY. 20 minutes from SUNY Oswego. Another gem!!"
List of local businesses, places and services in New York
⭐ business help 🔍 services ☎ phones 🕒 opening times ✍️reviews 🌍 addresses, locations 📷 photos