Elizabeth's Pizza & Restaurant

"AWFUL experience today at Elizabeth's!! We got there 8:25 pm, made our order and were clear that we wanted to dine in. After a long wait, the food showed up at 9:07 pm in to-go boxes and when we asked they said they had closed 7 minutes ago and wished us good night!!!!! I mean more than 40 minutes to prepare 2 pizzas?!!! If you did not think you would make the order in time, you should have been clear about it from the beginning and we would have had a pleasant time somewhere else!!! But I guess you had to make those extra 65 bucks (+18% tip for nothing) before you closed!!"

"Just looked at overall rating and should have paid more attention to the recent ones. Stopped by for dinner, seems run down, half the dining room is closed and stacked full of pizza boxes and junk. Sign says to order at window no servers. They ask for a tip while paying by card then have signs posted at every table to clean up after yourself. Food for dine in came in paper bags like a to-go order, in plastic and styrofoam containers with plastic utensils. Got pasta dish, was disappointing overall, bread served with it was flavorless and hard like it was stale. Tiramisu was not good at all, didn't finish it. Single trash can by door was overflowing with all the disposable containers, bags and cups so had to play jinga to throw stuff away. Overall will not be back, wish I had seen recent reviews highlighting how this place has gone downhill in the past year!"

"Worst pizza I’ve had in Fayetteville. Undercooked, floppy, soggy, with zero crisp. The pizza was so undercooked the cheese wasn’t even melted."

"First time at Elizabeth's and was very impressed. The staff was friendly and accommodating. Orders are taken at the kitchen counter, but when we arrived, we were not yet sure what we wanted to order. So the wait staff offered us extra menus to look at and said we could sit down and take our time. We ordered the Deluxe and Vegetarian. I asked if I could substitute the eggplant on the Vegetarian with spinach, and they said I could. The pizzas are thin Brooklyn style. The Deluxe was delicious. They add basil to the pizza which added a nice pep to the pizza. The veggie was very good as well. Both were very cheesy. There is also a bar and dessert / coffee shop attached where you can order alcohol. So if you like beer with your pizza, it is convenient. Definitely recommend."

"One bite, everyone knows the rules. Pizza is 7.3. A little greasy but good. Atmosphere was a bit stiff & lacking. Seems like they're more just a takeout place now."