Sofia Pizza Shoppe

"Solid pizza here, especially their pepperoni pie/slice. Wouldn’t get pizza anywhere else in the area!"

"Unfortunately, when you decide to order any of their whole pies for delivery via DoorDash or Ubereats, you’ll likely receive them cold and hard as a rock. The one star rating may not reflect the atmosphere, however if you choose to work with delivery companies you better ensure to the best of your abilities that your food is delivered in the way it was meant to be received. The past several times we ordered for delivery the boxes were exposed to the winter weather ie rain, snow; recently the pizza we got was burnt black on one side. We wanted to give this place a chance but given these recurring issues, will no longer order from them."

"This place was my fave for real Italian pizza & came here weekly to get pizza and chat with the 2 Brothers who owned the place but in recent months has gone down. The lady at the counter who dresses for the beach in winter has trouble understanding simple orders, is rude, can't multitask as you can see by other reviewers has trouble understanding delivery orders & acts discriminatory and rude toward the delivery drivers. Also gets belligerent when you try to explain things she doesn't understand then casts you off for other customers. As another reviewer said she touches herself & then the pizza. I've been coming here since they opened & love the food but will not return unless you please remove this nasty, unprofessional worker. She represents this fantastic landmark to all your loyal customers which you are losing due to her who are going next door to Marinara."

"I tend to stick to pepperoni, but the seasonal looked good. It has hot honey, vodka sauce, two kinds of cheese (fresh mozzarella), caramelized onions, and pepperoni. It was a small shop with three stools that faced an open window. Service was so friendly. This New Yorker was impressed. I'll go out of my way to go back."

"Nut free and gluten free options. Delicious! Adorable pizzeria. Small inside with limited seating. Very much enjoyed our pizza with our allergy family. Highly recommend."