Gotham Restaurant 12 East 12th Street, Manhattan, New York,

"Outstanding experience, we enjoyed the Wednesday night live jazz band. Our meal was delicious. The oysters were delicious, tuna tartar a must! the cauliflower soup went great with their house made fresh bread. main courses were amazing and presented wonderfully. The wine selection is very extensive. staff was very helpful from coat check to servers even management would come by to check on us and ask if everything was well. I will definitely return again or bring friends from out of town to enjoy this beautiful and great ny restaurant experience. loved how they any left over to go for you by coat check."

"Great atmosphere. An upscale new American restaurant with fresh ingredients. We had the duck which is really good and fresh and a large portion and then we had the steak which did come out undercooked quite a bit and then honestly I didn’t love that they just threw it back on the grill and it came out all different sorts of cooked throughout. The french fries were very expensive and very cold, so that was a bummer if I had noticed before I probably would’ve sent them back. Good meal I’d probably come back, but the prices are high for what you’re getting."

"Review from a Feb 2023 visit. Massive variance between the price point and our experience for the evening. I've heard amazing things about this restaurant over the years but it would appear the changing of the guard after the pandemic has caused a noticeably dip in quality. The service was objectively great, very attentive to detail and friendly/informed, no issues with adjusting meals for the vegetarian in our group. The interior felt and looked cramped in certain areas as the evening got busier. And lastly for the first half of our visit there was staff and maintenance working on fixing the AC, we were very cold while waiting for our first dishes and greeted with occasional burning/dirty smells while they were working on a fix. The meal itself was good, nothing revelatory in terms of new flavors or ideas, just quality ingredients made well. For a few specific weak points - the truffle pasta special was just not worth anywhere close to the price, and the root veg on the roast special were under seasoned. Chocolate tart for dessert was excellent."

"Outstanding experience! I give them my outmost recommendation. First, we had a special occasion to celebrate and we highlighted this in our reservation. The receptionist carefully reviewed the reservation notes and seated us accordingly. Joseph was a gem and set the tone for the evening. This definitely elevated the experience from the first moment. The service delivered by the waiters were perfect. I mean it perfect! The food was delicious and the drinks was refreshing. To conclude, would definitely love to come again And I definitely recommend it."