Carlo's Pizza 3182 U.S. 9, Cold Spring, NY 10516

"I was pleasantly welcomed by Carlo's Pizza's attentive and friendly staff from the moment I walked in. The tone for what turned out to be an excellent supper was set by their sincere enthusiasm for their work and commitment to providing outstanding service. Let's discuss the main attraction, the pizza! The menu of Carlo's Pizza is outstanding and offers something for every palate. Each pizza is a marvel, from the traditional Margherita to the gourmet variations. The toppings are consistently fresh and plentiful, the crust is wonderfully thin and crispy, and the sauce is hearty and tasty. With each bite of the Margherita, in particular, I was immediately transported to Italy thanks to its straightforward yet tasteful combination of tomato, mozzarella, and fresh basil."

"We ordered pizza for a last minute send off snack for our wedding guests at The Garrison on 06/02/23. We contacted Carlos’s Pizza through email and Deisy was quick to respond and very helpful. They were also able to accommodate our delivery time request at 9PM to our wedding venue (they close at 9). All the guests enjoyed the pizza as well! Would definitely recommend working with Deisy for any event! Thank you so so much for everything! Joanna & Terence"

"Food was delicious! Very clean establishment and has an inviting atmosphere! Would recommend for anyone wanting a nice dinner and great experience!"

"Today we discovered that Carlo’s prepares breakfast! We had a delicious breakfast! Fresh blueberry banana pancakes, corned beef hash, scrambled eggs and also a Breakfast burrito, everything was really great! The restaurant offers outside dining and is super clean and new. The server Gerber was so nice and attentive. When we left, we promised to come back soon. Also their pizzas are great. And one of us used their bathroom and it was spotless clean too. Five Stars for this Pizza restaurant with a full breakfast and lunch menu!"

"New to the area and saw this place was highly rated. First time the pizza we got was amazing. Second time we got pizza there it was mediocre at best. We chocked it up to a busy night and a flop order. It happens. Then we ordered pizza again and the pizza was not worth the money. Last week, I was exhausted from work and didn't want to cook so my husband ordered Shrimp Parm and I got a Chicken Marsala, not nearly what I was hoping. I again gave it the benefit of the doubt, must just be a busy night. Fine okay. I order here today since I work in the Medical Field and going out isn't an option for me (it would be selfish for me to possibly subject others to whatever COVID exposures I may have had). It's my anniversary tonight, and I wanted to treat my husband to a special meal so I ordered him his favorite, Chicken Francaise dinner meal (entree, small salad, choice of pasta, bread) and I just ordered chicken tenders with honey mustard. Let me just say, what a let down. It would have been better to have exhausted myself after a 12hour day and cook than to order here The food arrived over 45mins late. That never happened before. My husband's dinner was cold and missing the side salad and bread. My chicken tenders (all 3.5 of them) were cold. Carlo's did decide to treat me to limp, soggy, cold french fries I never ordered. And laid my chicken tenders on them. The honey mustard that the website states the tenders come with was missing. I paid full price and tipped head of time online upon placing my order. And this was my food and service? Disappointing."