Pizzaiolo by Brothers 85 Godwin Avenue Shopping Center, Midland Park, NJ 07432

"I rarely write reviews, but I felt it was necessary to mention the horrible bad attitude and incompetence of the wait staff that we encountered on Saturday night. Our server was Jorge, and he was not only annoyed that we needed service, but he screwed up our orders. He also barely knew how to open our wine bottle. We found a ton of cork inside & he was clueless. All our food came out together, and everything was wrong. We sat waiting for an explanation and some sort of acknowledgment, but he pretended that he did nothing wrong and looked annoyed with us. We had to ask the bus girls for help, yet they couldn't understand English.The bus girls basically did everything for us and not him. The only reason we know his name is Jorge is from our bill. He was successful at turning our evening into a "bad taste" in our mouths. We attempted to ask for help from the other waitress who kept walking.She completely ignored us as well. We overheard her table complaining also. We finally got our check, which took another long torturous wait . These prices and horrible incompetent servers constantly change. No organization, just chaos. It's a shame the father, who was the original owner, had such a different approach, and I remember him when I was a kid.This was the worst dinner date night experience we've had in a long time. They need better professional servers and a few more servers working cause these two by far can't handle it. We planned on ordering takeout for our kids & their friends, but we couldn't get any service, so we decided to order from elsewhere. We ordered online from Rosario's just right across town. We've always received a warm welcome & great service there. They have professional waiters and great Italian food at Rosarios. We regretted not going there to begin with. Also, we booked our next Monthly Catered office party thru them, and we love to support small businesses around us. We needed to share this because it's a huge disappointment. The horrible bad attitudes of wait staff that don't care or attend to their guests. They are overwhelmed & incompetent. We couldn't find a manager, and the counter staff was a bunch of teenagers. It was just a final and last dinner for us there. There is no need to torture ourselves again."

"Consistent, tasty, good quality food. Sometimes minor mistakes are made, like throwing bread in the main bag when taking out food. That is a do not do. So we threw it out and considered it a mistake by a young person working there. Clean, bright interior. Perfectly good."

"First off, let it be known that I ABSOLUTELY HATE pepperoni pizza! However, the Hot Honey Pepperoni is TOO GOOD FOR WORDS! They don't always have it, but when they do I can't leave without getting a slice, regardless what else I'm having. I've been working my way down the menu and there hasn't been a single meal that I would not have again. If you are a Broccoli Rabe connoisseur, they do it the right way (with a little bitterness). Just like the way my family does it in Naples Italy. Staff is super friendly. Everything is clean and spotless. Covered outside dining is great when it's not too hot or cold to be outdoors. I'm happy I'm local to this place because I would be burning through a lot of fuel if they weren't."

"This is a fine place with a beautiful atmosphere. The service it good, the interior design is almost perfect, and the food good. But my one big complaint is they claim to make brick oven pizza and it’s more like faux brick oven. First of all there is no break oven to speak of. It is actually a modern stainless steel oven in the shape of a brick oven and I believe it’s gas powered. That being said the pizza is definitely good but it’s really missing that natural flavor you get from a traditional brick oven set up. It tastes more like a standard American pie. On the bright side, the focaccia bread is pretty good and the Barata cheese is amazing."

"Our server was wonderful!!!! We were visiting from Minnesota and I forgot my socks. She directed us to Marshalls. She was very friendly and kind. The food was terrific as well. We got a blackened chicken Caesar salad and it was delicious!!!!"