Steinhilber's Restaurant

"The food was top notch. The shrimp was outstanding and very fresh. Both fish dinners were perfectly cooked and loaded with flavor. The ambiance in the building was very rustic and while it was a bit loud with so many guests, that didn't take away from the warm and inviting tone. The problem rested solely with our service. My wife and I were celebrating our anniversary and this place came highly recommended. Our waiter initially greeted us and was super friendly and outgoing. He explained the menu and the different wines and cocktails on offer. When I explained that we would not be drinking and just ordered iced teas, his entire demeanor changed. We got our order in, but the service was sparse at best after. We were not checked on, we were not offered any refills on our drinks, and we waited a solid 20 minutes after we had put our utensils down before someone different came and cleared our table. That nice gentleman also brought us our check at our request as the waiter had passed by our table three times without so much as a glance. The feeling we got was that we were no longer worth his time because the bill wouldn't be as high without the alcohol, so he thought his tip wouldn't be as good. Everyone else gave outstanding service from the hostesses, to the gentleman that cleared our table, all the way to the valet."

"Love this place! I made reservations about 3 weeks in advance for my mom’s 50th birthday dinner. Once we arrived, the host and staff were very inviting and friendly! They got us seated and we had 2 of the best waitresses (Katie and Amanda)! They made sure we were very well taken care of the entire night. They even stored the birthday cake we brought in with us, cut and served it. The food was amazing and the atmosphere was just so intimate. I would definitely recommend this place for a date night or special event! 10/10!"

"This was our first time visiting and we really enjoyed ourselves. The service is top tier. The servers wear coats, ties, and look sharp. The venue is beautiful, cozy & comfortable. The Scallop Casino is a superstar dish! The other dishes (Beef Wellington, Shrimp Cocktail & Key Lime pie) were fantastic, but I took a star away because of the Lobster Thermador. It seemed like the lobster meat was removed from the tail and added to the pasta side dish that accompanied it. The pasta and sauce are delightful, and you still get a large lobster claw to crack and enjoy, but I prefer the sauce baked on top of the tail intact. It's truly a special place that we hope to frequent for years to come."

"This place is cute. There are nice lights and lots of flowers decorating the outside seating area. They have fire pit tables which will keep you warm and cozy during your dining experience and the warm fire brings on a beautiful romantic ambience. We got the paella which was absolutely delicious. The seafood pasta was a little on the salty side and a little spicy. It was just okay. We also got the shrimp which was delicious and very nicely prepared fried in a batter. The halibut was a generous portion of halibut. It was nicely done and delicious. This restaurant is really nice with it's ambiance during the evening with all the small lights."

"Today was our first time eating at this place and we were celebrating our 4 year wedding anniversary! There is not enough Stars to rate such a wonderful experience! We were greeted and had our door open by the valet attendee, next the greeters, then the waitresses was so attentive and last but no least the food was the greatest of all flavors!!! We really enjoyed the beautiful view, music, and it was worth every dime. For once I didn’t feel like we were throwing our money away! I love it here and plan to come back! Thank you all for bringing me back to the home of Great Customer Service!!!!"