Sportsman's Supply Co 245 Freeport Road, Butler, PA 16002

"I was sold the wrong item. Trying to communicate with their customer service was awful. Now I’ve been ghosted. Don’t do business with them, they aren’t worth it"

"This stores Gunbroker has completely went down hill. I remember the good old days when you could buy ammo and actually pick it up in the store. Now all they sell is trash ! They don’t even have a firearm listed for sale out of there 680 posts, but if you want a first aid kit, swords, gloves, hats, cheap holsters, or a jig head for a cleaning rod they got you covered. If you want to look at firearms or something useful like ammo they won’t have it listed. Keep up the good work as a second rate auction house !"

"They are mostly geared towards online sales now. The selection of used guns is always decent. Most of the employees are generally helpful."

"Apparently they are now under different management, because the service I received was fantastic, despite the older poor reviews. Staff was personable and got me what I needed."

"Tried to buy a crossbow on GunBroker but the transaction didn't go through so I moved on to something else then a few days later I still get charged for it and when I tell them I don't want it now they say it's gonna coste $500 restocking fee so the only options are purchase the $2000 crossbow or give them $500 this is criminal"