John's of Arthur Ave.

"Confusing place. Detroit style is absolutely fantastic. Tastes like NYC Sicilian with a pan crust. However, their actual Sicilian looks and tastes like frozen supermarket pizza. I threw away the plain slice while eating there. If you're gonna charge $5/slice for the Detroit, it is delusional to charge $4 for that Sicilian slice. Super friendly staff besides one rude younger counter girl. They may have fired her though, not sure. You CLEARLY can do better pizza. Do it if you want to keep borrowing the "John's Of" name."

"$46 for a 3 topping pie? What on earth!? We are in MILFORD PA!!!! Food isn’t even great or we wouldn’t complain. Told 40 minutes and we were early - iced cold!!! Having to put a brand new $46 pie in the oven and we live a mile up the road!! We are so disappointed. This place needs to read their reviews and reevaluate their business!"

"The best Calzone and some of the best pizza we’ve ever had!! So cheesy and soft and perfect flavor combos. The place had a great aesthetic and super friendly staff as well! My only complaint is how hot it was in the restaurant due to the ovens- making it an ideal takeout/delivery place but not good for sit-in in hot weather. Probably fine in the winter though! Was the perfect road trip rest stop- will be making coming through Milford to stop here a travel priority in the future when possible."

"Cute pizza shop near the NY border. We stopped here on the way back to CT from TN. The pizza was good, mostly due to the cheese. The mozzarella was excellent. The wings were pretty good, standard Frank's Red Hot with some butter. The mozzarella sticks were perfectly cooked and had the same cheese as the pizza, likely the same sauce. The garlic knots were also good, although due to being jarred garlic it wasn't quite as potent as I was hoping. The service was quick, the food came out super hot and fast. I would definitely stop here again if I was in the area."