Frewsburger Pizza Shop

"We tried it because none of us had ever tried it and it was right across from the bowling alley we spent a few hours at. I ordered a Buffalo chicken tender sub with extra ranch, provelone cheese, Buffalo sauce, no onion, no tomatoes. I got no Buffalo sauce at all. Extremely light ranch. Extremely overcooked hard dry gross chicken. Tomatoes. Over toasted dry bun. I got up and asked for a cup of Buffalo sauce and a cup of ranch. I was given ranch and just a cup of hot sauce not Buffalo. I just took it because obviously I was somehow asking way too much of the place. Nothing saved it. I threw more than half of the sub away it way dry hard and gross. The Hawaiian was okay not good not bad. We'd get it again in a pinch, but wouldn't go out of our way. Torn older plastic table clothes. Carvings in the wooden walls. Talking to a few locals at the gas station kitty corner to the pizza shop about it being a lack luster experience they agreed that the chicken finger sub sucks. They said they only get wings there 90% of the time rarely ever pizza. All three locals in the gas station said the honey mustard wings and medium wings are their best things on the menu. We might try them again to see if the wings are okay. All 3 of us were very unimpressed."

"Definitely a nice place to stop for food pizza and wings. Super busy on a Saturday with walk-ins and call-ins but theybwere busting it out! We waited about 15 minutes for dine in."

"Frewsburger Pizza Shop in New York has won my heart as a go-to destination for mouthwatering pizza that never fails to impress. With its exceptional quality, flavorful toppings, and friendly service, Frewsburger Pizza Shop is a true gem for pizza enthusiasts. From the moment you step into Frewsburger Pizza Shop, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza engulfs you, instantly igniting your appetite. The cozy and welcoming atmosphere, coupled with the friendly staff, creates a delightful dining experience for both locals and visitors alike. The pizzas at Frewsburger Pizza Shop are a testament to their commitment to excellence. Each slice is a masterpiece of flavors and textures. The crust is perfectly baked—crispy on the outside, yet delightfully soft and chewy on the inside. The generous toppings are fresh and carefully chosen, creating a harmonious combination of flavors that will leave you craving more."

"Went in late but they were very accommodating. Food was good. Didnt expect it to be that big.. fine job guys.."

"All locals know this place and they know they know their locals. If you are from out of town, stop here. Starting with slices at lunch, including cupped pepperoni that get a nice char, there is a solid range of pizza shop standards where the pizza ovens work tirelessly. From pizza, sandwiches, Stromboli, and wings, they twist the normal pizza shop menu with "fat bellie" sandwiches, which use pizza dough instead of bread. They have the normal regional sides like pizza logs, but throw in curves with sidewinder fries and a jumbo pretzel."