Luke Nightingale, MD 1111 Hudson Avenue, Stillwater, NY 12170

"Time for him to retire. Horrible experience. Won't help you at all. I went elsewhere after 2 appointments. Very judgemental. Front desk women and nurses however are very professional and friendly."

"Was there for surgical clearance, in a wheelchair because leg had 5 fractures. Asked me if I was able to brush my teeth. Clearly , that was not the problem.."

"I have been a patient of Dr Luke for approximately 18 months and would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a PCP. The staff at the practice are always friendly and available help with any health-related issues. So, if you're looking for a facility with kind knowledgeable professionals who "treat you" like family and not a numbered patient, then come on down to Stillwater! where everyone knows your name and you be glad you came."

"Arrogant. Went here to see him only twice and zero labs were drawn no blood work up as most doctors do with new patients. My second visit yes second visit this man walks into the exam room 30 minutes late without even asking what is going on. He blurts out "busy weekend at the hospital for you, you have anxiety and need a psychiatrist" I was flabbergasted. I said excuse me. He was rude and cold hearted. I called my two specialists after leaving there who said YOU DO NOT HAVE ANXIETY. Had he even took time or had proper knowledge he would know any spike in blood pressure would cause anxiety like feelings and that my blood sugar has been running high. But never even listened to me about it. Stay away from this guy he is one of these doctors who is trying to diagnose everyone as having anxiety without checking to make sure that they don't have an underlying condition before trying to put them on psych meds or telling them to see a psychiatrist. I have never had anxiety in my life nor do I now. This doctor is ridiculous. This man has only seen me twice and for him to make a diagnosis because he's in a bad mood and put that on my permanent record is completely unprofessional and I have filed a complaint with the office of Professional Medical conduct."

"I used to go here for doctor Fatone and loved him. When Nightingale took over I came to him 20 times over the same issue which he kept trying to take care of with melatonin gummies instead of sending me to a psychiatrist. I suffered with anxiety and depression for months before I finally went to the ER and they referred me to the psychiatrist where I got the help I needed. I only go here when I have no choice."