Pat's Pizza of Presque Isle

"Terrible. 3 of us got cut off after 2 beers. Said it was too much cause I didnt order food. Waitress was nice. Manager will probably run it into the ground."

"Pat’s Pizza in Presque Isle offers a delightful dining experience with a mix of flavors and local charm. We started with the chicken nachos, featuring homemade chips that added a satisfying crunch. The large pepperoni pizza, adorned with mini pepperoni, was a cheesy delight! Although today the pizza had a subtle hint of horseradish (or something) that left us with mixed feelings. The restaurant’s ambiance is enriched by local sports decor, creating a cozy atmosphere. The friendly waitstaff added a personal touch to our visit, and the quick service ensured we didn’t have to wait long to indulge in Pat’s Pizza’s offerings. Overall, a tasty spot that captures the essence of Presque Isle."

"I went in, ordered a pickup, was told 45 minutes, great ran errands and set a timer on phone for 40 minutes. Got back to Pats, picked up went home and pizza was ice cold, well room temperature. For a place that says they sell crispy thin crust, this pizza was mush crust. If indeed the pizza was hot and fresh, I think it would good pizza for a pizza deprived Presque Isle community. I will try again sitting at their cozy little bar!!! Returned!! Sat at the bar, great friendly server, great beers. Probably one of the best bar pizza in years! !!!"

"Was seated pretty quickly around 5:30 on a Thursday night. Seated at the bar, which was fine. We came early to eat before a play at the local college. We placed our order, and it still had not arrived by 7:00 (hour and a half later). We asked to just pay the bill on our beers, and (presumably) the manager quickly asked us "if we still wanted our food". We said yes, even though we were now late for our play. Fifteen minutes later the food arrived (now an hour and forty-five minutes after ordering). My cold sub sandwich did not contain the vegetables I ordered, and was very very overpriced for what it was. My guest was overcharged for their calzone (charged extra for the two toppings that were included). Note as well that the draft Tubulars are $11 (eleven dollars) each. So, $60 and two hours later, we finally got to scarf down our food and rush to our show 20 minutes after it started. No apologies from the staff about the delay, no discount, no updates on the delay. Extremely disappointed, this is not the local icon it once was."

"Unfortunately have to change my review upon reopening. The pizza is almost the same, but the crust is different. My biggest complaints however is the service. I've been to the new Pat's three times in their first week. Only once was my order correct. On top of that, there is serious animosity going on amongst the waitresses. Openly arguing and being nasty to each other in front of customers during a lunch rush that wasn't even that busy."